All true, but the article is deeply misleading nonetheless. All of those quotes are from when Gandhi was still in South Africa, BEFORE he became a freedom fighter/activist for Indian independence. He would later go on to deeply regret his racism and to work with Black leaders in the US and elsewhere. It's unfair of the article to use those quotes without contextualizing them, because the fact remains that the Gandhi who became famous was not the same Gandhi who made those racist statements- he was the Gandhi who abandoned his racism. At the time he made those statements, he didn't even believe India should be independent and was still c00ning for the British empire. Some of those quotes come from when he was barely out of his teens, and even the most recent one is still a decade before he actually sparked the Indian independence movement.
I'll just quote myself from an older thread on the same subject:
It's a shame that the Black Star doesn't have higher standards of journalism. Producing needless disunity is a mistake, and giving a misleading picture of a man who actually did deliberately put in work for the Black cause around the world is wrong. It would be like someone writing an article about Malcolm where all they mentioned was that he gave massages to old White men.
I'll just quote myself from an older thread on the same subject:
Actually, there is, but unfortunately that information isn't widely available because the sensationalism of his earlier racist views gets more publicity for whoever is publishing it while the latter is just run-of-the-mill anti-racism.
One source I recommend is this book:
It details how Gandhi both sent representatives to the US to dialogue with Black Civil Rights leaders and how several Black Civil Rights leaders visited him in India, and the interactions they had. Gandhi even wrote for the legendary Black newspaper Crisis and personally corresponded with W.E.B. Du Bois.
And Che never changed his views about the indigenous peoples of South America. He was a Dances With Wolves/Last Samurai/Avatar type dude through and through- basically an upper-class White guy who identified with the dark-skinned natives and wanted to lead them, but simultaneously considered them in a paternalistic way.
It's a shame that the Black Star doesn't have higher standards of journalism. Producing needless disunity is a mistake, and giving a misleading picture of a man who actually did deliberately put in work for the Black cause around the world is wrong. It would be like someone writing an article about Malcolm where all they mentioned was that he gave massages to old White men.
Last edited: