BOTW >> OoT
Both games are overrated and the franchise is overrated in general. But BOTW had more legs. The world was worth exploring and was fun. The durability system made your trips feel like journeys you had to be prepared for. And the game managed to be somewhat challenging unlike the others.
I remember my grandma rented OOt and megaman 64 (megaman legends) for me at blockbuster one summer. Ran thru megaman quick, game was fire.
Oot was a drag...messed around and quit at the water level and didn't re-rent it to finish. Most Zelda games get boring 75% thru. Twilight princess and BOTW are the only Zeldas that kept me entertained through completion.
Misnch cap, oot, MM, alttp all got dropped around midway.
Only people that consider OoT a goat game irl are whiteboys
And would it kill these dudes to switch it up on the final boss fight? Is it me or do you fight an easy ass pig gannon on a horse at the end of every 3D zelda?