I was all up and down the Kings Disease thread on The Coli and on social media when the announcement was made. There was definitely anticipation and people were pleasantly surprised that Nas was working with Hit-Boy. Of course you had you’re “ Nas should be working with Alchemist/Premo/Pete Rock” trolls, but even that was few and far in-between. Most of the debate was, like you said, on if the tracklisting was real. I didn’t believe the tracklisting was real at FIRST because of the number of guest features (the most on a Nas album since IWW) and The Firm reunion but YOU actually convinced me; but that had nothing to do with Hit-Boy himself or his production, it was just going by the logic of previous Nas releases.
Once they dropped Ultra-Black as the single there wasn’t much chatter about “wack beats”; it was more about the controversy of him calling out Doja Cat.