Nas- Magic 3 Discussion Thread
- Thread starter Slim Charles
- Start date
ArchStanton
All Star
Yeah, by the sounds of it I think he will be double-locking his apartment door tonight and checking his closet for Nas.
Agree with this take. For me the top 4 albums from this run (KD2, M1, KD3, M3) are generally the same quality, but the marginal differences come down to overall lyrical performance/concepts.
KD3 - Clearly the best overall, everything came together. Nas' sharpest lyrical performance in the run, long satisfying verses, concept tracks, good beats.
Magic 1 - While it lacks the concept tracks and depth of say KD3 and KD2, it's arguably Nas best and most consistent showcase of flow in the entire run. Literally sounded like IWW/Lost Tapes level flows, effortless
KD2 - Imo the album with the most interesting, lush production, good concept/themed tracks, nice features but is honestly held back from its potential because of Nas performance. Hes great of course, but if he rapped with the intensity, flows and lyricism of KD3/M1 it would undisputably be the best project in the run.
Magic 3 - Very strong, the return of vintage storytelling Nas, but the lyricism is not quite at the level of KD3 and I think he had better flows on M1. I wanted a little more production wise too, which is why I have it at 4
"Magic 3 mostly just sounds like another solid Nas and Hit-Boy collab, but without a doubt their least interesting material of the series. This album lacks new direction and feels like leftover tracks of Magic 2 packaged together as an add on."HipHopDX review
Nas and Hit-Boy’s ‘Magic 3’ Is More Cliffhanger Than Grand Finale
HipHopDX brings you the Nas & Hit-Boy Magic 3 Album Review which was released on Thursday September 14, 2023. The duo drop off their last collab with more of the same, but it works.hiphopdx.com
3.8/5. I feel like the reviewer was kind of reaching to find something to criticize for. He mentioned Pretty Young Girl as a low point when in my opinion its one of the strongest joints and he singles out Nas rapping against A.I. as something bad saying that fans would rather hear Nas rap about street shyt (again, putting him in the Illmatic box)
But have a read for yourselves
This sounds nothing like Magic 2, HipHopDx is just like PitchFork when it comes to Nas smh...
Wayne got Nas stans in their feelings
JayBaldacci
All Star
Yeah, it's all opinions... and I don't think Magic 2 is bad, just the worst of the series and not near Magic.
Saw the comment regarding his health and recent productivity
Don't think he has any issues but believe there is a connection between him aging, the covid world stopper, less bullshyt happening in his personal life, finding a crime partner in chauncey that can actually deliver dope beats that suit his taste so the planets just aligned for this.
And to hear that there are rumors for more... I'll give my wishful thinking as well: would like to hear the material that was overseen by Joshua Kyambo Hiphop, the Timbo, Sinatra in the sands stuff, just really curious about that
Other than that I'd rather not criticise anything and say that I very much appreciate this output, salute to both of them !!
Don't think he has any issues but believe there is a connection between him aging, the covid world stopper, less bullshyt happening in his personal life, finding a crime partner in chauncey that can actually deliver dope beats that suit his taste so the planets just aligned for this.
And to hear that there are rumors for more... I'll give my wishful thinking as well: would like to hear the material that was overseen by Joshua Kyambo Hiphop, the Timbo, Sinatra in the sands stuff, just really curious about that
Other than that I'd rather not criticise anything and say that I very much appreciate this output, salute to both of them !!
Hit been getting way more love than hate honestly. I’ve been saying after KD1 dropped, was hot, and won the Grammy he’s been good money for those that matter in the industry.
Dude executive produced for Big Sean, Benny, and did full albums with Dreezy and Musiq Soulchild. He just said on Twitter he’s going to take some time off and then work on his father’s debut album. He also said him and Alchemist got something coming
ArchStanton
All Star
You mean a 15 song album isn't leftovers from a 10 song album?"Magic 3 mostly just sounds like another solid Nas and Hit-Boy collab, but without a doubt their least interesting material of the series. This album lacks new direction and feels like leftover tracks of Magic 2 packaged together as an add on."
Where the hell did he come up with that leftover idea? The math ain't mathing. And like you said the styles are totally different.
Somehow I skipped that paragraph of the review, but now I see the review is dumber than I thought on my initial read.
Prolific_1011
All Star
I love how Hit Boy understood the responsibility that comes with producing for Nas. Dude embraced the challenge and gave it his all. The result is phenomenal.
Last edited:
