Nas - Magic 2 (Discussion thread)

Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
64,774
Reputation
27,786
Daps
385,391
Reppin
Ft. Stewart, Ga
The problem is yall are so absurdly protective of every single Nas decision and career move that yall keep resorting to histrionics and Straw men at the mere suggestion that people would rather hear Nas with other producers.

TO ME, I enjoy the KD albums but they're not hitting me on the level where I don't think other producers would do a better job, I threw out Alc as an example and here comes Ziggiy pulling out some white savior BS straight from his ass. That's it. Plain and simple. I don't think I know what's best for Nas, I'm just saying what I'd personally rather hear so you guys can leave all the projections for either your mama or the candle lit vigil of Nas posters in your room.

I think Hit Boy is leagues better than guys like Swizz, Irv Gotti, Ron Browz, Duro and a bevy of other wack nikkas but that's really the whole thing - the fact that so many worse producers have gotten the same high profile credits as Hit Boy shows fukking dumb of an argument it s to simply use credits to prove that one sude is better than the other. Because I can tell you any rap fan is getting laughed out the building if they try to tell you some of them wack ass late 90s producers are GOATS just cause they worked with Jay, Nas, etc.

Even rap fans with broader tastes be shyting on Swizz Beatz wondering how they ever liked his shyt but by Ziggiys logic he's the GOAT :mjlol:

And y'all still can't seem to make up your mind between what sells and what is quality. Y'alls big joker when defending Hit-Boy against any other producer seems to only be sales when we know DAMN WELL that ain't indicative of anything, and even comparing the sales of a legacy artist like Nas to an underground rapper is inherently fallacious because Nas has 30 years of a built up fanbase and nostalgia - his sales, which aren't much stronger than Benny or Freddie to begin with, are on the back of his whole catalogue, not just what he's doing now.

Like you wanna say Hit-Boy is an elite producer because of nikkas In Paris, when that was not only a divisive beat among hip-hop heads like us, not only was it pretty much just a preset loop he found, but even Hit-Boy himself has tried to distance himself from that beat and prove he's more capable than that. So like, what are we doing here?



You didn’t come in stating “In my opinion”. You tried to pass off stating that Hit Boy was a B Tier producer as a FACT to prop up Alchemist. Here is your initial post

Y'all gotta stop pushing the same tired strawmen to defend Hit-Boy. He has great chemisty with Nas but he's still a B+ producer and there's nothing wrong with wanting to hear guys like Alc et al for a full, focused project with Nas...a full project, not just some throwaways since I know y'all like to treat The Lost Tapes 2 like the big joker in any argument in Hit-Boy's favor :mjlol:


It was so retarded that I figured you were trolling and I didn’t even respond to you. Then you quoted ME as I was responding to @kes929 (A poster I actually respect to have discourse with) outlining to him the reasons why it made absolutely ZERO sense to categorize Hit Boy as B Tier with this
Do you know how many mediocre producers in this day and age have major star credits?

We can't talk about major stars making mediocre microwave music etc but then in the same breath use a producer working with them as your sole argument of their capabilities
When I challenged you to find me ONE B Tier producer who has EXTENSIVE with the likes of Jay-Z, Nas, Kanye West, Nipsey Hussle (including Grammys with all three) Kendrick Lamar, Drake, Mary J Blige, and others you hemmed and hawed until naming Swizz Beatz. I countered with the notion that, whether you like Swizz or not, calling him B Tier with his 25 year record of hits and CONSISTENT placements amongst the most elite of artist was absurd. The problem with your postings is that you have NO verifiable facts whatsoever to back up anything you cLaim. You claimed that an Alchemist produced Nas album would be head and shoulders better than the current Nas produced Hit Boy albums. I countered that notion with FACTS to the contrary, because again, there is NO verifiable metric with which to make that claim. Nas and Hit Boy have outsold EVERY Alchemist exclusively produced project released in the last five years. So there‘s ZERO financial reason to believe fans give a fukk more about Alchemist as a name than Hit Boy. KD1 won the Grammy over Alfredo. So there’s ZERO merit or accolade based reason for Nas to pick Alchemist over Hit Boy. KD3 is more acclaimed than ANY Alchemist based project from last year, and equal in acclaim to Alfredo. So there’s ZERO critical or review based reason for Nas to pick Alchemist over Hit Boy. All you have is your OPINION. And OPINIONS are all well and good but when you try to pass off OPINION as fact then you better damn well have SOMETHING to back that up or you just come out looking one of two ways. Either like an idiot or someone who just thinks the white man’s ice is colder.

You claim you went to the Madison Square Garden Kings Disease concert and you couldn’t even back THAT UP with any factual claims
I was at Nas' King's Disease Trilogy concert in MSG...and I'd wager 60% of the concert was his 90s classics and it's what got the strongest engagement from the crowd. Y'all talk about being stuck in the 90s and shyt, but the entire idea of being a Nas fan in 2023 is inherently stuck in the 90s. People are gonna always say "We want Premo!" and such because that's the Nas work that's made the strongest impression on the vast majority of his fans and why they still listen to him to this day.

Here’s the set list for the Kings Disease concert



And if THAT doesn’t jog your memory, as supposedly you were there, here’s an official source



Out of 34 songs performed, 22 were from KD1-3 and Magic. Now i’m not a mathematician So maybe you can educate me or perhaps you were using The Metric System, but 22 songs out of 34 does NOT add up to him performing 60% 90’s classics. You FAIL time and time again to back up anything you say with FACTS.
 

CrimsonTider

Seduce & Scheme
WOAT
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
82,289
Reputation
-13,974
Daps
130,373
2 things and im outta here :russ:

Mannn...Ziggy and Life is Good make every Nas thread a hilarious read. Both you guys look craaazy with your Stanning its weird as fukk honestly. Get help.

And...
Cant wait for the album :ahh:
This thread is the height of comedy. Nas Stan’s are a treasure.

I keep getting negged too :mjlol:
 

FunkDoc1112

Heavily Armed
Joined
Sep 14, 2013
Messages
19,414
Reputation
5,813
Daps
101,390
Reppin
The 718
You didn’t come in stating “In my opinion”. You tried to pass off stating that Hit Boy was a B Tier producer as a FACT to prop up Alchemist. Here is your initial post




It was so retarded that I figured you were trolling and I didn’t even respond to you. Then you quoted ME as I was responding to @kes929 (A poster I actually respect to have discourse with) outlining to him the reasons why it made absolutely ZERO sense to categorize Hit Boy as B Tier with this

When I challenged you to find me ONE B Tier producer who has EXTENSIVE with the likes of Jay-Z, Nas, Kanye West, Nipsey Hussle (including Grammys with all three) Kendrick Lamar, Drake, Mary J Blige, and others you hemmed and hawed until naming Swizz Beatz. I countered with the notion that, whether you like Swizz or not, calling him B Tier with his 25 year record of hits and CONSISTENT placements amongst the most elite of artist was absurd. The problem with your postings is that you have NO verifiable facts whatsoever to back up anything you cLaim. You claimed that an Alchemist produced Nas album would be head and shoulders better than the current Nas produced Hit Boy albums. I countered that notion with FACTS to the contrary, because again, there is NO verifiable metric with which to make that claim. Nas and Hit Boy have outsold EVERY Alchemist exclusively produced project released in the last five years. So there‘s ZERO financial reason to believe fans give a fukk more about Alchemist as a name than Hit Boy. KD1 won the Grammy over Alfredo. So there’s ZERO merit or accolade based reason for Nas to pick Alchemist over Hit Boy. KD3 is more acclaimed than ANY Alchemist based project from last year, and equal in acclaim to Alfredo. So there’s ZERO critical or review based reason for Nas to pick Alchemist over Hit Boy. All you have is your OPINION. And OPINIONS are all well and good but when you try to pass off OPINION as fact then you better damn well have SOMETHING to back that up or you just come out looking one of two ways. Either like an idiot or someone who just thinks the white man’s ice is colder.

You claim you went to the Madison Square Garden Kings Disease concert and you couldn’t even back THAT UP with any factual claims


Here’s the set list for the Kings Disease concert



And if THAT doesn’t jog your memory, as supposedly you were there, here’s an official source



Out of 34 songs performed, 22 were from KD1-3 and Magic. Now i’m not a mathematician So maybe you can educate me or perhaps you were using The Metric System, but 22 songs out of 34 does NOT add up to him performing 60% 90’s classics. You FAIL time and time again to back up anything you say with FACTS.
I'll admit I was wrong about the setlist and was going off memory but the rest of this rambling is you being unable to discern the fact that every post I'm making is an opinion. I called Hit-Boy a B+ producer - I didn't see he was a B-list producer, that was just my flippant way of saying he's pretty good but there are better guys but you seem unable to comprehend that. Your "facts" of sales are already shaky because Nas isn't selling much better than those guys to begin with and has the benefit of being a legacy artist, and then your other facts are metacritic score... a collection of OPINIONS. Not only a collection of opinions, but opinions you guys were quick to throw in the bushes when they were lukewarm on the first two KD's so weight do they really have in this argument?

And if you want me to prove i was there, here ya go. I don't like posting my picture on here because I look like a Tubi-casted Lloyd Banks but whatever:




Regardless of how much of the setlist was classics, they were what he closed the show with and got the most response from fans.
 

Bobhoward

Baseball Ready
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
681
Reputation
75
Daps
1,488
Has there been anything besides the teaser last week? I’d assume something is dropping but it’s gonna be hard for me to read through 38 pages of stanning.. I’m a nas fan but some of these posts are multiple paragraphs of rambling
 

ThirdAct

Superstar
Joined
Jun 15, 2017
Messages
8,239
Reputation
2,019
Daps
39,172
Has there been anything besides the teaser last week? I’d assume something is dropping but it’s gonna be hard for me to read through 38 pages of stanning.. I’m a nas fan but some of these posts are multiple paragraphs of rambling

Very reliable reddit poster that gave info about KDII, Magic and KDIII before they came out says its Magic 2 dropping this Friday
 

bigdaddy88

The King Of Power
Joined
Jun 18, 2014
Messages
14,516
Reputation
3,742
Daps
65,919
i agree with the alchemist is overrated or more like he fell off.. But besides the babble where the album at ????

There is a reason i dont follow rappers or whaetver on social media , i only care about the bars and the beats .
 

MikeStamina

All Star
Joined
Jul 3, 2018
Messages
3,747
Reputation
-455
Daps
9,669
Alchemist is one of the Goats it’s been a common opinion on forums since I was posting on AHH in 09 since then he’s done nothing to waver that opinion, it’s nothing to do with Hit Boy who is a great producer himself but ALC has bonafide classics dating back to the late 90’s and he’s still producing tracks like Johnny P Caddy he deserves all the props in the world.



How any of this proves a 4 album run with Nas would be better than Hit's is where we're fukking lost at .....
And if y'all agree Alc 4 album run won't be necessary better than Hitboy's (what it is vs what could be)
Then wtf are we talking about



@Ziggiy
Steve Wonder can see these cats can't handle you in a debate. Not on this topic anyway....Your only misstep being the Alc white savior thing...
 

MikeStamina

All Star
Joined
Jul 3, 2018
Messages
3,747
Reputation
-455
Daps
9,669
This ain’t even a hit record. It was everywhere on mixtapes tho. But some shyt like this is better than every beat Hit has produced for Nas. lol. And I think the Hit Boy Nas albums are classics.




So what you're telling me is on those 4 albums, no beat is better than this????

Hysterically laughing out loud like Shaq right now
Falling out the chair n all

Damn Spliz....I hate it had to be you
 
Top