There's a lot of amazing instrumentation on that album. While his peers focus on finding the next hot producer, the album is another example of him finding top tier musicians to help bring his vision to life. This time, Duval Timothy, who does much of the piano work throughout the album. All that being said, the album almost certainly will not be in my (rap) top ten this year. And I don't think Kendrick matched the prowess of his collaborators this time.
Will the album win a bunch of Grammys, including the rap album one? Of course. It's an interesting album with some fascinating stuff on it, I just think he needed someone in the studio to tell him a looot of his shyt wasn't wavy on the album. In my opinion it has his worst rapping and lyrics, out of all his projects overall. Certainly there are some standout tracks on there where he knocks it out the park in those regards (Father Time, Mother I Sober for instance).
There are multiple parts of the Jid album that make me miss when Kendrick used to rap/perform like that. Kinda depressing. Still a huge fan/stan and looking forward to his next album though.
Man, I think that's where I feel like a bit of an outsider lately.
I love Hip-Hop but almost all of the music I find myself listening to lately is either Jazz (Jazz Hip-Hop like Alfa Mist or Robert Glasper or Jazz Fusion or contemporary Jazz), heavily Jazz influenced (Left Field Hip-Hop, Boom Bap, Neo-Soul, "Lo-fi"), prog metal/rock or classical. I've also only recently started to try to learn Arranging & Composition in earnest and I've started purchasing texts by David Baker, Ted Pease and Ken Pulling and so on. While broadening my understanding of Jazz harmony and how it's works in modal and "normal" harmonic contexts . So for me, when I returned to Hip-Hop more heavily in the latter half of this year (where I finally truly listened to Mr. Morale & The Big Steppers), I found myself repeatedly "wowed" not just by the lyrical density but in the structure of the songs and the harmonic choices underneath.
It almost feels like a redux of "To Pimp A Butterfly" but with a focus on bringing in instruments with a different timbre than those that appeared on that album (distorted 808s, strings sections, piano playing that's distinct and different from the Blues/Jazz/R&B tradition etc.)
I totally understand if it isn't for everyone but I really dig the "fukk ***'s" to Hip-Hop convention which feature on that album, I also like that it embraces Hip-Hop in earnest again doesn't try to be "different for the sake of different". I was kinda shocked to see that there is seemingly even more of a divide over that record on The Coli.
I think the album is better than DAMN. But even with that. I don’t feel it’s all THAT. I think it’s cool. Especially for an album off a 5-6 year hiatus. Kendrick gets praised more than any nikka I ever seen in rap by the media and a nikka like Cole doesn’t get extended this same kind of artistic grace when he tries some different shyt so it is what it is imo. To each his own tho I’m not tryna change no one opinions.
I feel that's a big issue that Kendrick deals with now. As a Hip-Hop head, I'll admit that I don't think Kendrick is the ONLY ONE doing cool interesting
things in Hip-Hop or that being "unique" should be the only reason we elevate someone.
For example Cole's last album was Hip-Hop through and through, it wasn't doing anything "new" but what it did do was deliver EXCELLENT Hip-Hop
which is just as important and I think people who are coming from the outside and only respect "special" and "unique" and "new" (to them of course, not to us, who are in the know) those people are evaluating Hip-Hop in the wrong manner.
With that said, you guys often don't see the people who deride Kendrick Lamar and in turn the entirety of Hip-Hop when he gets all of that praise.
Many, many people who railed against "To Pimp A Butterfly" and the rewards Kendrick received also would go on to say said Hip-Hop isn't Music/Musical nor Poetry and that he (Kendrick) nor any other rapper deserves respect.
It's rough because I feel like I need to defend Hip-Hop at times and it's frustrating but I see how great it is as a fan and as a participant yah know ?
I'll readily acknowledge other cats are trying dope things like JPEGMAFIA, Lupe Fiasco, Elzhi, J. Cole etc.
I don't mean to stray to far off topic though:
King's Disease 3 is fukking great, seriously.
This thing Nas has going on where he's dropping albums yearly is crazy !