IllmaticDelta
Veteran
No its not. you are projecting your insecurities. You think because i said with out west indians theres no hip hop that i think hip hop was started by jamaican immigrants and aas tagged alone. None of which i said
I'll put it like this...HipHop as a culture from it's start was basically always aesthetically and culturally based in AfroAmerican traditions from rapping (Jive Talk, The Dozens, Hokum Blues, Jazzoetry), HipHop Dance (Jazz Dance and then later Soul/Funk dance) and Graff (Dudes from Philly in the mid 1960's). This is the source for what later became HipHop. Now as I pointed out before people of West Indian descent like Herc played a roll in the early HipHop jams for sure but I can't say he created anything new. The evidence doesn't support it.
Im not really trying to discredit Herc. Infact, I give him credit for being aware that his crowd wanted to hear Funky songs and observing that many people in his crowd would start bugging out/dancing during the parts where the singing dropped out and all you heard was the Funky drumming parts. By him noticing that, he helped initiate ONLY GOING TO THE BREAK PARTS. I can't give him credit for discovering the idea of knowing about the "Break" because Disco DJ's were already doing this, they just didn't dwell on it. Now, I can't five credit to Herc for the art of rapping because we know for a fact that syncopated rhyming to the beat was already being done by Disco DJ's around 1970 and 1971 outside the Bronx. That didn't come into play in the Herc scene to about 1976/1977. To go further back, the syncopated rhyming to a beat had been going on way back since the 1920's/1930's. Songs with true Funk beats were being made pre-HipHop since the 1960's. Herc says he never rapped in the syncopated rhyming form and numerous people that attended his park jams also attest that he didn't. Yet, people keep trying to link the art of rapping to Jamaica through Herc
Grandmaster Flash on Herc:
"His style was basically freelance talking"
Everything Baambatta cites in the last paragraph for the roots of rapping is AfroAmerican in origin