The neoliberal consensus is in part what caused the current political climate. People were angry that there was no change, people are still angry. So, indicating a return to more of the same respectability politics without a shred of economic justice is just kicking the ball down the road.
Eventually, the next guy up will be like Trump, except more competent and in an environment where the president can demonstrate autocratic leanings and the people are burnt out on the "threat to democracy" card.
EDIT:
The only way I could see a neoliberal consensus working is if the GOP agrees to settle down on the culture/social war issues.
I don't expect either party to negotiate on behalf of the common people. While the Republicans can come to the table about taxes, corporate handouts and spending, I don't see them coming to the table on social/ culture wars issues and that would break any discussions of both parties coming to a consensus and bringing the Overton window towards the actual center.
And even such a consensus is a nonstarter considering the worsening immigration crisis. We haven't even seen the shape of the nightmare to come once climate change really kicks in and suddenly there are waves of migrants fleeing their countries.