Joe Montana is still the GOAT in my eyes

[mastermind]

picking and choosing 1 good season is a losing argument.

Your entire argument was based on you picking and choosing one season.

 

[Jplaya2023]

So it’s about regular season?

Montana got owned by the giants in the playoffs in 86 and 90. He never faced the bears at their peak


Yeah he got owned by the giants at their peak. 86 and 90. When they were actually Super Bowl contenders. Congrats on beating a 9-7 giants team in 1981.

So now the argument is at their 'peak' you cant make this shyt up. The team that won those games went on to win the SB

 

[Street Knowledge]

So now the argument is at their 'peak' you cant make this shyt up. The team that won those games went on to win the SB

You wanna brag about beating an 9-7 giants team in 1981 be my guest.

Now that I think about it who was the best team Montana beat in the NFC playoffs? The 12-4 Danny White led cowboys in 81? Or the 12-4 88 Bears who were nowhere close to their peak of 85?

The best non 49ers teams from 1980-1991 he either loss to or never played them


1983 Redskins
1985 Bears
1986 Giants
1990 Giants
1991 Redskins

 

[Jplaya2023]

You wanna brag about beating an 9-7 giants team in 1981 be my guest.

Now that I think about it who was the best team Montana beat in the NFC playoffs? The 12-4 Danny White led cowboys in 81? Or the 12-4 88 Bears who were nowhere close to their peak of 85?

The best non 49ers teams from 1980-1991 he either loss to or never played them


1983 Redskins
1985 Bears
1986 Giants
1990 Giants
1991 Redskins

The NFC title game was the SB then. The 85 bears 86 giants are 2 top 10 teams ever. Your acting like not playing or losing to them is some type of black mark? 83 Skins top 15 team ever. Hell the niners got jobbed on a bad PI call in that game after coming back 21-0

Rank these 4 teams

83 skins
84 49ere
85 bears
86 Giants

 

[mastermind]

You wanna brag about beating an 9-7 giants team in 1981 be my guest.

Now that I think about it who was the best team Montana beat in the NFC playoffs? The 12-4 Danny White led cowboys in 81? Or the 12-4 88 Bears who were nowhere close to their peak of 85?

The best non 49ers teams from 1980-1991 he either loss to or never played them


1983 Redskins
1985 Bears
1986 Giants
1990 Giants
1991 Redskins

Oh shyt

 

[Ethnic Vagina Finder]

nikkas is cherry picking just to throw shade on Montana

 

[mastermind]

Jim Everett from 88-90

Even defeated the ‘89 Giants at the Meadowlands with over 300 yards.

 

[JLova]

Your entire argument was based on you picking and choosing one season.

Not true but you’re trying to tell me the league today aren’t geared towards the offense. All the rule changes to benefit offense but youre saying there’s no difference. GTFOH!

 

[dakidblu]

Joe aint had a case since the rams got shyt on in the sb the second time. Compare him to manning or something he aint fukking with tom

 

[JLova]

nikkas is cherry picking just to throw shade on Montana

Cats really acting like Joe would have had a tougher time in todays league.

 

[Juggalo Fred]

Joe aint had a case since the rams got shyt on in the sb the second time. Compare him to manning or something he aint fukking with tom

You mean the Superbowl where Brady doesn't throw a touchdown and quarterbacks the defense to only allow 3 points?

Yeah that really was impressive

 

[Rekkapryde]

This is why I enjoy NFL commentary more than the NBA

Youre allowed to have your GOATS at any position so long as you have a case, youre allowed to explain why, and FACTS can be acknowledged. agree or disagree.

Aside from the fanboys, You typically dont have a wave of extremists who call the feds on you because you said one guy was better than the other guys.


honestly The only true undisputed GOAT in any major sport is Wayne Gretzky, because there have quite literally been no disputes made.

Agreed on Gretzky. That shyt is asinine

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

Almost all of the 5000+ yard seasons and 40+ TD seasons have come the last decade or so. More QBs w/ 30+ TDs than ever before. More QBs w/ 4500 yards than ever before..


"but O'Brien had a great year once... " Dumb argument

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

The best non 49ers teams from 1980-1991 he either loss to or never played them

1983 Redskins
1985 Bears
1986 Giants
1990 Giants
1991 Redskins

Another dumb argument.... Those teams weren't at "their best" because the 49ers ran the fuccing decade.

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

nikkas is cherry picking just to throw shade on Montana

Matt Stafford has 5000 yard seasons and 40+ TD seasons but 1 pro bowl. Jameis had a 5000 yard season and isn't a starter on most teams... Dumb arguments all around the thread