With no Soto, teams can afford to not pitch to judge again, which makes him a less effective player. Outside of Judge, does anyone else on this team scare any pitcher? Remember what the back half of 2022 was like where nobody would pitch to judge unless the bases were empty? Only 21 of his 62 homers came with someone on base. That’s not good. 62 homers should lead to at least 14-16 more RBI’s than he got that year, but nobody pitched to him when men were on because he had no protection in the lineup. A near 1.000 ops doesn’t grow on trees. We hadn’t seen anyone get on base like he did aside from Judge since Jason Giambi. 41 homers speaks for itself, but a .288 average and .420+ OBP is borderline irreplaceable too. Go look at the rest of the roster. Outside of jazz, the next highest batting average was .247 and he & wells were the only other guys to have even a .310 OBP on the year. You can’t replace that sort of production and that goes double for October, where Stanton is now the only hitter on the team you can trust. If losing Soto wasn’t catastrophic, what moves do you think there are to be made that can replace him? Since 2020, the only other Yankee to have even an .850 ops on a year besides judge was 2021 Stanton. It’s been years now of them being unable to fill out the rest of the batting order. In fact he’s the only other Yankee batter besides Judge since 2021 to hit even .275 on a season.