It Was Fun While It Lasted: The Official 2024 New York Yankees Off-Season Thread

tremonthustler1

aka bx_representer
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
83,165
Reputation
8,998
Daps
205,934
Reppin
My Pops Forever RIP
Given how Guerrero says he’d never sign with the Yankees even if he were dead, that’s another 1 year rental waiting to happen :martin:


sign this beast in 2026. Still just 24.

If they wanna trade Spencer Jones in some deal for Crochet/Robert, I'm with that too.

The biggest hole really is 2B or 3B depending on where Chisholm plays long term.
 

BK360NATL

Pro
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
712
Reputation
230
Daps
2,330
Reppin
NULL
Cashman should get on the phone with Toronto and see if they’re willing to trade Vlad Jr.
Nah, there's generational hate for the Yankees here, based on how we treated his father. His father legit wanted to play for us. We chose Gary Sheffield instead. I was 100% Team Vlad back then.

Jr. never forgot and continues to hold that grudge. He'll end up at Citi Field.
 

Mantis Toboggan M.D.

Drink wolf cola
Joined
Mar 18, 2014
Messages
31,929
Reputation
9,656
Daps
107,265
Reppin
Brooklyn

Like the lakers after Jerry Buss died. Most of these names were of the “didn’t even try” variety. None of the shortstops or Realmuto they even tried to get.

the Harper one by far hurts the most.

1. Harper

2. not acquiring Verlander in 2017 via trade

3. Machado
I said as sooner as Verlander got to Houston it would burn them, that they’d pay for not going all in. All 3 needed to be here. By 2019 they had by a few metrics the worst starting 5 in baseball and I don’t think anyone has gotten worse play from left field, first base, or third base than they have since passing on these guys.

We all thought Bryce to the Yanks was a formality smh
Harper held out for us so long that the MLB the show 19 cover with him on it released with him in a hoodie because he was still a free agent. He signed with the Phillies a few days after Cashman signed hicks :scust:
 

Mantis Toboggan M.D.

Drink wolf cola
Joined
Mar 18, 2014
Messages
31,929
Reputation
9,656
Daps
107,265
Reppin
Brooklyn
I forget the reasoning behind not even trying for Bryce. Was it the Stanton trade?

Never understood it and still don't. Made zero sense then and to this day.
No logic at all. They used his deal as an excuse but they went into 2018 with a payroll $30 million less than the 2017 squad and just 2 years later Ellsbury’s deal would expire anyway, which was 85% of what Harper is being paid. Instead they spent more on washed up starters and relievers.
 

Tim Dripcan

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Mar 25, 2015
Messages
5,229
Reputation
3,950
Daps
26,465
Given how Guerrero says he’d never sign with the Yankees even if he were dead, that’s another 1 year rental waiting to happen :martin:

The Yankees need to ask for an extension before they give up all their assets for a guy like Vlad. Or repeat the same fate.



sign this beast in 2026. Still just 24.

If they wanna trade Spencer Jones in some deal for Crochet/Robert, I'm with that too.

The biggest hole really is 2B or 3B depending on where Chisholm plays long term.


Wouldn’t be surprised if he goes to the Dodgers
 
Top