Is Rey a Mary Sue? (Star Wars related)

[Mic-Nificent]

no the fukk it doesnt.


She was on jakku fighting bums and peasants with a stick so now she's a better fighter than a sith lord trained by luke and snokes?

Takes on a group of elite guards trained to deal with people like her and wins, even when those guards are about to kill that sith lord, she saves his ass.

Her only experience is fighting hobos and garbage diggers.

In their first fight Kylo was Severly injured, he took a direct shot from Chewbacca's bowcaster, the same weapon that we saw send Stormtroopers flying through the fukking air.

The fight scene in the throne room is after she had received training from Luke.

 

[Mic-Nificent]

None of that helped Luke not get his hand cut off. Or Anakin either.

Luke was fighting a full fledged Sith Lord and Anakin was fighting a Jedi Master that was also his teacher.

Kylo Ren hasn't mastered anything by the time we firirst meet him, he's just very powerful. And like I said in another post Kylo was fighting Rey after taking that blast from a bowcaster.

 

[Neuromancer]

Luke was fighting a full fledged Sith Lord and Anakin was fighting a Jedi Master that was also his teacher.

Kylo Ren hasn't mastered anything by the time we firirst meet him, he's just very powerful. And like I said in another post Kylo was fighting Rey after taking that blast from a bowcaster.

True, your points are vaild. Thank you for backing your claims.

 

[Devilinurear]

She knew exactly how to use Jedi mind tricks just because she recalled hearing about it before. She had no prior training.

That's not the same as luke and anakin having heighten senses in a dire situation, which is how the force has been shown to work for people with no training.

Keep trolling like you don't know the difference tho.

I sorry I don't know how a made up power works.

 

[Neuromancer]

I sorry I don't know how a made up power works.

You don't seem to now much about SW and yet here you are.

 

[Devilinurear]

Defeating everyone you've ever faced in combat.

This helped the resistance how?.

Her knowing how to fight really helped them from being killed. But she won the battle because that is all her character cares about.

 

[Devilinurear]

You don't seem to now much about SW and yet here you are.

You don't understand how characterization works yet here you are.

 

[Neuromancer]

This helped the resistance how?.

Her knowing how to fight really helped them from being killed. But she won the battle because that is all her character cares about.

I don't even know her motivation let aline what her flat character cares about.

 

[5n0man]

In their first fight Kylo was Severly injured, he took a direct shot from Chewbacca's bowcaster, the same weapon that we saw send Stormtroopers flying through the fukking air.

The fight scene in the throne room is after she had received training from Luke.

He wasn't that injured considering he went to see snokes right after that fight, before going to the med base, and the injury is never mentioned.

And even if he was injured, that was literally her first time picking up a lightsaber. He was stopping blaster bolts in the sky but he couldn't stop this girl that just found out she can use the force?

Luke trained her for what, a day?
How long was luke training kylo? Years maybe?

Then snokes trained kylo for a few more years?

And with all these years of training, kylo would have got killed by those red guards if not for Rey the nobody.

And those red guards were trained well enough to damn near cut kylos(a sith lord) head off, but they must not be shyt compared to those junkers Rey fought on jakku cause she washed them nikkas.

And she washed Luke too, why did she even need training when she's already stronger than him.


Seems like Rey should have been training Luke.

 

[Neuromancer]

You don't understand how characterization works yet here you are.

When you see some in this fallen franchise you let me know.

 

[Devilinurear]

He wasn't that injured considering he went to see snokes right after that fight, before going to the med base, and the injury is never mentioned.

And even if he was injured, that was literally her first time picking up a lightsaber. He was stopping blaster bolts in the sky but he couldn't stop this girl that just found out she can use the force?

Luke trained her for what, a day?
How long was luke training kylo? Years maybe?

Then snokes trained kylo for a few more years?

And with all these years of training, kylo would have got killed by those red guards if not for Rey the nobody.

And those red guards were trained well enough to damn near cut kylos(a sith lord) head off, but they must not be shyt compared to those junkers Rey fought on jakku cause she washed them nikkas.

And she washed Luke too, why did she even need training when she's already stronger than him.


Seems like Rey should have been training Luke.

She taught him to believe in the force again.

 

[5n0man]

I sorry I don't know how a made up power works.

Yet here you are trying to debate about something you don't know shyt about.

 

[5n0man]

She taught him to believe in the force again.

Master Rey and padawan Luke

 

[Devilinurear]

When you see some in this fallen franchise you let me know.

That Asian chick and poe where done well. And Finn grew. I just don't think ray is a Mary sue. She sucks as character In So much as luke sucked as character
I think Vader had the best ark.

 

[Devilinurear]

Yet here you are trying to debate about something you don't know shyt about.

I thought the debate was about ray being a Mary sue

If it was just about her being overpowered in the force l sure why not. But her character does not fit the narrative of a Mary sue.

Superman and Batman now those are Mary sue.
Lara croft in tomb raider.