Is Mike Evans A HOF Player?

[Big Boss]

Yes

 

[murksiderock]

For those who don't think he's a Top 5 receiver of his era, I'd ask you who you'd say ARE the Top 5 receivers of his era? His career is 2014 to now...

No order, there's AB, Hop, Julio, Reek as the four greatest since '14. After that, there is no definitive #5, as you could argue for several guys. Evans certainly has a case as being the 5th guy of his era...

But shyt, thinking about that, I don't know that just "having a case" as the 5th guy is good enough, so I'd probably lean no, now. You kinda have to definitively be a Top 5 guy of your era to me to warrant The Hall...

He'll probably get in, but as others pointed out, Holy is still waiting, and he was better than Mike. Under no criteria should Mike be viewed as a lock...

 

[stepbackj34spud]

No. Never all pro.

 

[Tasha And]

Every receiver ahead of him on this TD list is either in the hall, still playing, or is named Larry Fitzgerald.

 

[AlbertPullhoez]

Yes he's a lock

 

[Sauce Dab]

He been putting up numbers with glorified backups QB’s throwing him the ball. He’s getting in

 

[AlbertPullhoez]

He been putting up numbers with glorified backups QB’s throwing him the ball. He’s getting in

Dude singlehandedly won Johnny Manziel the Heisman and got him drafted in the first round

 

[JLova]

Dude also balling when most of his career he played with mid (at best) QBs.

 

[Rekkapryde]

ONE all-pro selection!

then you agree that Eli shouldn't sniff the HOF

 

[Rekkapryde]

No problem with him being in but not first ballot.

If Chris Carter, T.O., and Mike Irvin didn't go first ballot them Mike should wait too

 

[BucciMane]

How is starting your career with 10 1K seasons subjective?

I said a subjective milestone. Does 1,000 yard season make you a HOF caliber player?

Let's move it to 1,300+ yard seasons and see where he stands.

 

[BucciMane]

People mentioning Issac Bruce, do you realize he had to wait quite a while to get in? And, with the talent at WR now and the numbers being put up, Evans would have to wait a while if he gets in.

 

[MikelArteta]

Every receiver ahead of him on this TD list is either in the hall, still playing, or is named Larry Fitzgerald.

Exactly like I said he's getting in and he's still playing. He might end his career top 3 in receiving tds

 

[Flex Luger]

No problem with him being in but not first ballot.

If Chris Carter, T.O., and Mike Irvin didn't go first ballot them Mike should wait too

This. The first ballot talk is crazy

 

[malbaker86]

Outside of Tom Brady for what, 3 years, he’s dealt with bullshyt QB’s and STILL had put up numbers.

He’s ABSOLUTELY a HOF