Is Mike Evans A HOF Player?

Stop_It_5

Veteran
Joined
Nov 19, 2016
Messages
14,805
Reputation
3,821
Daps
95,894
Hollt has become the measuring stick for "if a WRs numbers aren't better than his how can they get in" - but Mike already crushed his TD total and is on track to exceed his yardage with less catches.

Having a great year at 30 with Baker throwing him the ball is the kind of production that starts to push his case towards too strong to deny territory.
 
Last edited:

mikishere

#byrdgang
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
11,449
Reputation
2,674
Daps
36,768
Reppin
NYC
How's it useless? I think he will likely get in, but he's had ONE All-Pro season. He's never been one of the three best at his position.

He's absolutely not making it first ballot, that's for sure.

Some of you are clueless on HOF voting. :mjlol: .

this. my answer is hell no. yeah he has HOF numbers in an inflated pass happy era, but when have we ever considered mike evans to be a top 3 WR at any point of his career? i could go as far as top 5 too. there are WRs with a way better resume than him who still aren't in. 1 2nd team all pro is a HOFer? :mjlol: . man if the GOAT QB didn't gift that dude a SB ring, this wouldn't even be a topic.
 

BucciMane

Kristina Schulman Bro
Supporter
Joined
Mar 4, 2015
Messages
33,685
Reputation
-2,664
Daps
75,374
Reppin
The Real Titletown
this. my answer is hell no. yeah he has HOF numbers in an inflated pass happy era, but when have we ever considered mike evans to be a top 3 WR at any point of his career? i could go as far as top 5 too. there are WRs with a way better resume than him who still aren't in. 1 2nd team all pro is a HOFer? :mjlol: . man if the GOAT QB didn't gift that dude a SB ring, this wouldn't even be a topic.

Agreed.

I'm not even saying he won't make it, but it's more of consistency than greatness. The HOF should be for all time greats.

ONE all-pro selection!
 

MVike28

right around the ACC
Joined
Jun 9, 2013
Messages
25,156
Reputation
4,643
Daps
104,030
Reppin
T.O.
this. my answer is hell no. yeah he has HOF numbers in an inflated pass happy era, but when have we ever considered mike evans to be a top 3 WR at any point of his career? i could go as far as top 5 too. there are WRs with a way better resume than him who still aren't in. 1 2nd team all pro is a HOFer? :mjlol: . man if the GOAT QB didn't gift that dude a SB ring, this wouldn't even be a topic.
1000%

Shocking how ignorant NFL fans are this thread is pure ignorance

The players peak is very key at no point in his career was he ever top 3 WR much less top 5 in the league
 

BucciMane

Kristina Schulman Bro
Supporter
Joined
Mar 4, 2015
Messages
33,685
Reputation
-2,664
Daps
75,374
Reppin
The Real Titletown
1000%

Shocking how ignorant NFL fans are this thread is pure ignorance

The players peak is very key at no point in his career was he ever top 3 WR much less top 5 in the league

Exactly.

He's an excellent WR and shows up every season. However, when has he been unquestionably a top five WR?

He's been more consistent than other WR's, but that doesn't make you a HOF player.
 

Ethnic Vagina Finder

The Great Paper Chaser
Joined
May 4, 2012
Messages
55,297
Reputation
2,890
Daps
156,425
Reppin
North Jersey but I miss Cali :sadcam:
Agreed.

He should be in already. He was elite and has more 1,300 yard seasons than Evans.

Most posters in this thread are apparently enamored with compoling 1,000 yard seasons, a completely subjective milestone.
Evans is averaging 15.4 yards per catch for his career which is elite.

Then there’s who is throwing the ball to him. **** played with great quarterback play for the bulk of his career.

Evans has over 1,000 yards this year with 5 games left playing with Baker Mayfield.
 

Mull

All Star
Joined
May 24, 2022
Messages
722
Reputation
165
Daps
2,723
If you’re going to put DeAndre Hopkins in your HOF Mike Evans should be in
 
Top