February 2007: ESPN
http://sports.espn.go.com/nba/playoffs2006/news/story?id=2493982
O'Brien: He is right up there with Kobe Bryant and LeBron James, who would also have won the championship if they were surrounded by the rest of the Heat. Physically, Kobe is the best of the bunch, but Wade brings a mental and physical combination that might give him the edge.
Shanoff: Yes. If you factor in a complete combination of skills, "clutch," likability and -- now -- winning, no player in the NBA is greater right now.
He has the ring LeBron doesn't have; the likability Kobe doesn't have; the "clutch" Dirk doesn't have; and the more all-around skills Nash doesn't have.
Sheridan: No. Kobe Bryant is, if you want to base it on pure talent. If I want one player taking the last shot for a title, it's Kobe. Furthermore, if I had to pick one player from the draft class of '03 to build a team around, I'd take LeBron because of his size, shooting and ballhandling superiority. That's not to denigrate Wade, but he's not the best. Not yet, anyway. But he is close.
Shouler: As the flavor of the month in a league where the title "best player" seems to change almost weekly,
Wade currently deserves the honor because he just led his team to a title. But this is subject to change if LeBron James has a similar stellar series or Kobe Byrant approaches another 81-point game.
Broussard: Wade is building toward a historic career. To me, his comp is not Michael but LeBron and particularly Kobe. The way I see it, Dwyane and Kobe are vying for second place on the list of all-time great two guards (LeBron being a three and with all due respect to Zeke from Cabin Creek).
I can't compare D-Wade winning a title with Shaq to MJ doing it several times without a dominant big man. Also, MJ dominated an era when there were dominant big men (real post players) in the league. There are only two dominant big men now, and one of them is Wade's teammate. For the most part, he's playing against a league of perimeter finesse players, which makes him likely to be more dominant with more gaudy numbers. So Mike is still alone on the throne.