How did a white guy create a more realistic portrayal of the hood than any black person in Hollywoo?

Piff Perkins

Veteran
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
52,692
Reputation
19,501
Daps
287,449
It’s not even that 50’s shows are unrealistic compared to the Wire. The problem is that the Wire is one of the best written shows of all time, and every 50 show has bad writing. The Wire is largely created and written by journalists and people who worked on great shows beforehand (Homicide). 50’s shows have extremely amateur writing, dialogue that intentionally mirrors social media, and staggers various cliff hangers that are simply idiotic to garner as much social media buzz as possible.

I can imagine 50 watching the Wire and determining he wanted to do something like that…but without the “boring” parts. Similar to a child (or man child) who thinks MCU is better than classic cinema.
 

FunkDoc1112

Heavily Armed
Joined
Sep 14, 2013
Messages
19,909
Reputation
6,203
Daps
103,838
Reppin
The 718
I refuse to watch this and Euphoria keep hearing about it won’t watch

Actually saw the first episode of Snowfall and it was just off
You can pretty much skip 70% of the first season of Snowfall and not miss much. It's definitely pretty weak starting out. Second and third seasons are strong as hell though
 
  • Dap
Reactions: ISO
Joined
May 14, 2013
Messages
2,304
Reputation
1,669
Daps
10,110
Reppin
NULL
I would say yes and no. Yes, in the Wire did a good job exposing the institutional corruption in the police department, government, education system etc. But the Wire did portray black people in a mostly negative light as all drug dealers, baby mommas and shooters with a tiny minority of regular black folks... when in reality, most black people in the hood in Baltimore are regular. If things were as bad as the white media makes it out to be in every hood in America, there would be tens thousands of murders every year, not a three digit figure that is the norm for most big cities and there would be people starving to death and shyt. Prolific black writer Abagond broke this shyt down years ago.

The Wire

Are you really going to trust a white policeman officer’s perspective of the hood? :skip:And the Wire was also inaccurate in glossing over all of the white poverty and white ghetto areas in Baltimore.:ufdup: I’ve lived in Maryland for over 20 years, and yes, there are white hood areas in and around Baltimore full of white trash on dope too. Ghetto white people on the Wire were portrayed as lost middle class wannabes, not generational poor white trash a couple generations removed from Appalachia like they are. :aicmon:

And no portrayal of the hood on film could ever compare to Boyz ‘N the Hood. :usure:I’m originally from the hood in Cali and that movie is not a movie, it’s a documentary of hood life in Cali in the early 90’s. :whoa:That nice clean looking hood shyt where nobody outside for a got damn reason because you could get murked walking to the liquor store. Cacs don’t understand that about Cali. They like “this ain’t the hood, it’s so nice and clean”.:unimpressed:

And black people rep Boyz ‘N the Hood. I see black folks wearing Boyz ‘N the Hood t shirts every summer. Even all the way out here in Maryland. The only people who love the Wire are cacs from my experience. :hhh:The Wire is mostly only referenced in memes and shyt even on this site. :ohhh:
 

SheWantTheD

Veteran
Joined
Sep 10, 2015
Messages
39,865
Reputation
2,182
Daps
99,026
I need to actually sit down and watch The Wire from start to finish.\

Have only seen random episodes when they aired on tv years back.

I remember a teacher (not mine) was putting the show on in class (lucky b*stards) back in high school.
 

WMG the 2nd

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Nov 18, 2016
Messages
13,904
Reputation
2,977
Daps
60,798
Lmao they used a lot of Maryland/dmv nikkas too. That’s where Chris from lmao I actually think he’s Wale cousin. And Slim Charles is Big G from Backyard Band from DC
Chris was a member of a gogo band
 

NinoBrown

Veteran
Joined
May 6, 2015
Messages
17,140
Reputation
5,075
Daps
79,418
Too many black writers and directors have these pigeon-hole one-dimensional views of black characters in these shows. Its like you are either:

1) "THAT nikka" that no one questions their gangsta; always in the streets and hardly gets into trouble with the law.

2) Some dirty henchman/follower of the main "that nikka" characters that's in the streets; somewhat clumsy and gets caught doing dirt.

3) Some educated black person that is a bookworm or some Carlton Banks-sellout; wears glasses and has no confidence.

4) Some bum ass lame dude that gets clowned by women; dresses wack and no mouthpiece.

Most of these writers are swirlers, bi-racial, or lgbtq influenced, that's all they know of the Black experience.

Straight black writers have no say in our portrayal....
 

Wild self

The Black Man will prosper!
Bushed
Supporter
Joined
Jun 20, 2012
Messages
82,483
Reputation
12,016
Daps
223,684
Most of these writers are swirlers, bi-racial, or lgbtq influenced, that's all they know of the Black experience.

Straight black writers have no say in our portrayal....

I'm talking about those DVD hood movies. No swirler/alphabet gang writer makes those films. Its usually the straight brehs obsessed with making their version of "Scarface"
 

BrooklynShow

Rookie
Joined
Aug 13, 2016
Messages
126
Reputation
-30
Daps
298
Reppin
Crown Heights Brooklyn
The Wire is great because the overall story is being shown from different viewpoints.
Shows like Money & Violence and Power, Top Boy etc are only showing viewpoint.
I was amazed watching The Wire when it came out and saw how hard it was for those cops to get wire taps. How they had to basically beg a judge. I couldn't imagine it being that difficult in NYC.
Also, the criminals in the show didn't seem larger than life like Ghost or a criminal mastermind like Tariq who can outsmart everyone.
Lastly, a lot of the acting in the Wire was very good. That's why many of them ended up starring in movies and other shows afterwards.
 
Top