There are many ways to evaluate Sunday and most of the pointed questions
were asked of the failed offensive performance Tuesday. Unlike their mates who handle business across the line of scrimmage, the
Cowboys defense put up a fight that we can probably point toward as “potentially capable of beating Arizona in a rematch.” The bar is not the highest ever, but it should be meaningful.
Kyler Murray definitely did not have an unannounced homecoming. Tom Rinaldi made sure we knew (several times) what Murray has done in AT&T Stadium. The record sounds impressive, but his level of competition has raised a million times over from his first appearance there against Houston’s Lamar High School until Sunday against the Dallas Cowboys.
But what makes him arguably the most impossible QB to prepare for and contain is that even at this highest level of football achievement — playing on the road against a divisional champion-caliber team in the NFL with all eyes on him — he still manages to appear the most gifted athlete, even among gifted athletes. Yes, you would rather play against Murray than
Tom Brady or
Aaron Rodgers, but you can at least sort of prepare for them. What human can do what Murray can do on the practice field? How can a player that tiny be faster than everyone? Also, unlike
Lamar Jackson or even Michael Vick, how can a player that elusive still put the ball in a bucket perfectly on difficult throws while on the run?
He is definitely beatable — just ask the
Detroit Lions — but, he asks questions of a defense on his day that are awfully unique.
The good news is that Dallas has answers. They have amazing athletes in their front seven and while we will concede this entire league is made up of 99th percentile humans, there are many opponents on the
Cardinals schedule that cannot match the tools that guys like
Micah Parsons,
Randy Gregory and
DeMarcus Lawrence have in terms of raw athleticism. Maybe Dallas has a roster that is equipped to deal with this unique skill set that is considerably different than dealing with a
Matthew Stafford or Rodgers.
How did Dallas do?
It depends how we frame this. All told, Murray’s day would be viewed as “good enough” from my perspective. He made some plays — at times spectacular — but by his standards, I submit he has had many days better than this. There are games in his career already when a defense had no answers. For Dallas, given it could play him again on the same field in 10 days or so, I suggest the Cowboys had some answers. Good ones. But, not enough.
Arizona scored on five of its first six drives and all of them were without the benefit of gift field position. The Cardinals put together drives of 83, 87 and 75 yards to build a 22-7 lead early in the third quarter. Scoring 22 points is more than acceptable, but six scores suggest that without some good red-zone stops, it could have been 38 really quick.
The Cowboys did trouble him. They kept him pretty well contained for most of the day and forced him to perform a few across-the-body throws into traffic that were dangerous and fundamentally unsound. Yet, he asked and answered those two challenges — one from his own end zone and one into the opposing end zone with real beauty and precision.
If Dallas is going to lament anything from Sunday as it prepares for a rematch against Murray that will color the historical accounts of this entire season and perhaps era, it would be that the Cowboys entered the game as the best third down and takeaway team in the league. We feared that this might be more of a competition-based metric. If you want third-down stops and takeaways, stack your schedule with bottom-half of the NFL quarterbacks to defend. Because the elite ones — those who win MVP awards or even receive votes for it — excel in converting on third downs and not turning the ball over.
To the chagrin of those of us who were fearful of this, Dallas did not stop him on third downs as the Cardinals converted seven of them and they also did not force a single turnover (despite having one fall into their hands in the end zone in what might have been the pivotal play of the game — other than the controversial fumble possibility in the final minutes). You might be able to get away with a bad third-down day with a few turnovers. Or you might be able to survive no takeaways with a great third-down day. But, you probably won’t survive both being poor.
Could that change in a rematch? Of course.
The flip side is that in that meeting, odds are really good that
James Conner,
Rondale Moore,
D.J. Humphries and maybe even
DeAndre Hopkins (unlikely) will be along for the ride. In other words, your best chance to beat the Cardinals and avoid them in the first-round draw, was this past Sunday.
And Dallas did not get it done.
Weekly data box: vs. Arizona