Funny you brought this up. I beat GoW a week or so and playing through horizon now.
It's no contest imo. Horizon is a B+ while GoW is an A
It (horizon) is a well polished assassin's Creed with potential
Maybe it's just not fair to horizon that I best GoW first, but , on the flip side I bought HZD first day and played it until I got side tracked.
Imo I'm don't feel the sense of progression like I felt with GoW. I'm level 33 in HZD and it's just like w/e. My weapons are better and more diverse but it leaves me wanting a little more. While inGoW, I felt there was a very clear path of progression and the sense of accomplishment was very high (like when you kill the queen, comparing to when you started out and 2 revenants and a draugar had me stressed)
The lore was better fed to the player in GoW, Mimir/Atreus>>> voice recordings,emails, holograms. Presentation in GoW is miles better no cut camera, minimal load times, random boat stories, jotnar murals actually got me interest in a mythology I only knew of through marvel. In HZD it just feels like exposition over load. I thought GoW felt more natural and unique. Plus any written text was usually brief.
Combat is better in GoW. While I love fighting the robo animals in HZD, alot of times I find myself wishing I had my Axe and could just beat the shyt out of these muthere fukkers. And the human enemies are annoying. I hate Everytime I have to go against them. I just don't feel as satisfied with the weapons (aside from the ropecaster, I took down a Thunderbird with that and felt
)
I think I'd be a lil more satisfied if I could mount alot more stuff and use it kinda like a mech. I would've loved to mount one of those thunder birds and come through blasting on these bytch ass deathbringers.
I think HZD has better HDR and environments tho.