Jimmy is 3 yrs younger & will cost less
Jimmy can also get a team to the SB
We don't need an elite QB in Siri's system...we need a guy w/ some mobility who can attack all 3 levels
If we draft well & sign 2 or 3 good starters, we win the division with Jimmy G
I don’t buy that.
Every offensive system in the NFL needs a top-level QB to be consistently competitive. Even Shanahan’s 49ers, which runs one of the most QB-friendly offenses in the NFL, traded three 1st Round draft picks to pick Trey Lance to replace Garoppolo. They wouldn’t have done that if they thought they could win with Jimmy G. They were looking for a guy with more upside.
Garoppolo doesn’t elevate teams to Super Bowls. He does just enough with an elite defense, receiving threats, run game, and offensive line around him. If all those things click at once, the Niners are SB contenders. If they don't, Jimmy G can't do anything for them. He’s basically Kirk Cousins, a better passer than Hurts, sure, but not the long-term answer the Eagles need, and certainly not worth paying the kind of money he’ll be demanding.
If watching Wentz and Darnold this season has taught me one thing, it’s that it’s not worth signing some other team’s castoff. If the Eagles are going to make a move for a QB, it should be with the idea of finding the long-term answer for the position. Anything else is just a waste of time.
And that leaves two options: 1) trade for an established superstar, e.g. Rodgers, Wilson, or Watson or 2) take a shot on a QB prospect in the draft. If neither option is a feasible one, the Eagles are better off running it back with Hurts next season, improving the rest of the team around him, and taking their shots at a QB in 2023.