I like how Eminem "can't make songs" when he is the only rapper who carries ENTIRE ALBUMS with barely any guest appearances, and barely any guests doing hook duties.
His songwriting skills are actually his biggest strength. He comes up with a concept, whether silly or serious, and sticks to it with his three verses, while usually handling the hook himself as well. Very few rappers are good songwriters. Sometimes they can't even stay on topic within a single verse.
You know more about Eminem's personal life than 99% of rappers - but he can't make songs? Just makes a bunch of fart songs and talks about killing pop stars? What kind of fukking Narnia are you living in?
For real...people are imagining what Eminem's fan base looks like, and passing that off as a real statement? "Oh, everyone who buy's Eminem albums only likes rap from so-and-so and so-and-so." Who sits back, and imagines stuff like this? Do you not see how weird and sad it is? (puts fingers in ears) la la la! Everybody who likes _____ also likes _____! La la la!
Most of the people here are really shytty critics, who can't articulate what they don't like about music, and who get such a big raging hate boner for certain rappers, they can't listen to music objectively anyway. Just a bunch of BS, page after page after page. Post an emoticon, make a shocking statement, jack off....wash, rinse, repeat.