If that’s the logic you want to go by, then Portland has done right by Dame over the years even with blunders like Collins and Crabbe. They just couldn’t get over the jump.That doesn't help the argument. Holiday made the all-star team. He's always been an all-star level player. Cousins was as well and he made the all-star team while him and AD were playing together.
2 playoffs in 7 seasons
8 playoffs in 11 seasons for Dame.
The biggest knock you could put against them is that they wanted too long to move CJ, which wasn’t all on them as it took Simons a while to emerge. You can also place blame that they didn’t upgrade their big man position even when it was clear they needed one because of Nurkic injury history.