Civil War | Discussion Thread | A24 (4/24/2024, Dir/Writer. Alex Garland, starring Kirsten Dunst)

Poetical Poltergeist

Precise and cold hearted
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
37,251
Reputation
5,429
Daps
121,383
Reppin
Mile in the Sky
I'm just gonna guess that those decoy cars that drove out were supposed to make it thru and he was going to exit in another vehicle to somewhere else. Decoys got clapped up too fast and the whole escape maneuver fell apart.
The decoys were just to buy time. Suicide mission for whoever was inside. Looked like possibly presidents fam. A trump move for sure :dead:
 

Micky Mikey

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Sep 27, 2013
Messages
15,998
Reputation
2,962
Daps
89,254
Great movie. I'm still a bit disturbed by some of the images in the movie. I've seen more horrific things but how it was shot really captivated me. Something about hit close to home.

The politics surrounding the war wasn't the point of the movie. I understand why they came up with such an illogical alliance of Cali and Texas being the "Western forces". Its meant to be besides the point. Plus there were subtle hints about the politics of it if you paid close attention.

The real point was driving home how terrible war is. The toll it takes on people at an individual and societal level. Its a warning to society about how treacherous and devastating a civil war would be. People, especially in America love to larp and fantasize about it but really have no fukking clue how devastating such a scenario would play out.

I give this movie a 9/10.
 

Left.A1

Superstar
Joined
Dec 19, 2017
Messages
19,762
Reputation
774
Daps
52,747
Great movie. I'm still a bit disturbed by some of the images in the movie. I've seen more horrific things but how it was shot really captivated me. Something about hit close to home.

The politics surrounding the war wasn't the point of the movie. I understand why they came up with such an illogical alliance of Cali and Texas being the "Western forces". Its meant to be besides the point. Plus there were subtle hints about the politics of it if you paid close attention.

The real point was driving home how terrible war is. The toll it takes on people at an individual and societal level. Its a warning to society about how treacherous and devastating a civil war would be. People, especially in America love to larp and fantasize about it but really have no fukking clue how devastating such a scenario would play out.

I give this movie a 9/10.
If that was the point why make a movie where the audience follows around a protagonist who doesn't seem to care much and is largely unbothered until things get personal. I think she undercuts that whole messaging... If the protagonist doesn't care or seems unphased why should I? Including the back story would have given the plot some actual stakes for the audience to care about to get through the runtime.
 

Micky Mikey

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Sep 27, 2013
Messages
15,998
Reputation
2,962
Daps
89,254
If that was the point why make a movie where the audience follows around a protagonist who doesn't seem to care much and is largely unbothered until things get personal. I think she undercuts that whole messaging... If the protagonist doesn't care or seems unphased why should I? Including the back story would have given the plot some actual stakes for the audience to care about to get through the runtime.
Everyone has their way of processing trauma. Her apparent apathy and callousness were just a defense mechanism she developed over the years as a war photographer. Also, you have to figure an experienced war photographer isn't going to react the same way to war the way a regular civilian would.
 

the elastic

livin' outside of the matrix
Supporter
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
17,595
Reputation
7,310
Daps
79,008
Reppin
the bay/norcal
Everyone has their way of processing trauma. Her apparent apathy and callousness were just a defense mechanism she developed over the years as a war photographer. Also, you have to figure an experienced war photographer isn't going to react the same way to war the way a regular civilian would.
And she cracks towards the end, even after all that callousness
 
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
68,518
Reputation
11,218
Daps
238,973
Reppin
206 & 734
Great movie. I'm still a bit disturbed by some of the images in the movie. I've seen more horrific things but how it was shot really captivated me. Something about hit close to home.

The politics surrounding the war wasn't the point of the movie. I understand why they came up with such an illogical alliance of Cali and Texas being the "Western forces". Its meant to be besides the point. Plus there were subtle hints about the politics of it if you paid close attention.

The real point was driving home how terrible war is. The toll it takes on people at an individual and societal level. Its a warning to society about how treacherous and devastating a civil war would be. People, especially in America love to larp and fantasize about it but really have no fukking clue how devastating such a scenario would play out.

I give this movie a 9/10.
You get it.
 

Jazzy B.

Superstar
Joined
Aug 8, 2013
Messages
16,275
Reputation
2,527
Daps
58,888
Movie was nothing but a bait and switch.

It was really about Journalists IN WARZONES and their ETHICS and how far they're prepared to go to get "the story" and "the shot"
 

Jazzy B.

Superstar
Joined
Aug 8, 2013
Messages
16,275
Reputation
2,527
Daps
58,888
Great movie. I'm still a bit disturbed by some of the images in the movie. I've seen more horrific things but how it was shot really captivated me. Something about hit close to home.

The politics surrounding the war wasn't the point of the movie. I understand why they came up with such an illogical alliance of Cali and Texas being the "Western forces". Its meant to be besides the point. Plus there were subtle hints about the politics of it if you paid close attention.

The real point was driving home how terrible war is. The toll it takes on people at an individual and societal level. Its a warning to society about how treacherous and devastating a civil war would be. People, especially in America love to larp and fantasize about it but really have no fukking clue how devastating such a scenario would play out.

I give this movie a 9/10.

Naw this movie was clearly about War Journalism.

The specifics and politics of actual war/conflict didn't matter.
 
Top