again, even if she's being detained over BS, she doesn't have the "right" to resist being detained. she doesn't have the right to fight it afterwards though. and yes, i agree it was BS.again..
being detained for..?
yall need to learn your rights, and quit rolling on your back like a dog whenever these folks say roll..
yall probably would've put your camera down, if he said so too
(Black Female) Student Arrested, Window Broken
- Thread starter hood b. goode
- Start date
Can't even agree with my Nubian princess. After he said she was detained for a traffic infraction she should have shut up and did what he said. She didn't have to roll her windows down but he was bout to let her off with a citation. Shoulda kept her mouth shut, rolled her windows down and signed the paper. Coulda went on bout her business and her life. Now a minor setback turned into multiple L's
And who the fukk rolls the window up on a cops fingers
And who the fukk rolls the window up on a cops fingers
Imyremeshaw
كن التغير الذي تريد أن تراه في العالم
She was not wrong for cracking her window half way, you are not required to put your window all the way down, only enough for the officer to see in the car because it was during the commission of a crime.
Where she fukked up at was when the officer ask her to step out she was being detained, she should of complied with his orders no matter how wrong it may have been.
But she was charged with battery on a law enforcement officer and resisting an officer -- one count of resisting with violence, and a second count for resisting without violence?
From watching the video how the fukk was she charged battery on a law enforcement officer and resisting an officer -- one count of resisting with violence?
Thats clearly the biggest mis-justice in this case.
Where she fukked up at was when the officer ask her to step out she was being detained, she should of complied with his orders no matter how wrong it may have been.
But she was charged with battery on a law enforcement officer and resisting an officer -- one count of resisting with violence, and a second count for resisting without violence?
From watching the video how the fukk was she charged battery on a law enforcement officer and resisting an officer -- one count of resisting with violence?
Thats clearly the biggest mis-justice in this case.
Uncle Kingpin
No Relation
The whole "knowing your rights" argument only applies in court, after the fact. You can be arrested/detained for any reason or no reason at all for 24 hours or more in very limited situations. She does not have to wind down her window, but she does have to exit the car when ordered or else she can be forcibly removed. She's lucky the cops have to wear cameras or she would have gotten beat up and charged w resisting arrest and assaulting a police officer.
SouthernBelle
#Feyonce
common sense would tell anybody- if the officer knew the law she was actually breaking, he would have no problem explaining while/before he had her cuffed..
shes allowed to crack her window.. by law..
but, let the-coli law experts tell it..
In fact the ACLU had a video and still says on their website to roll your window down half way. I bet many coli guys would bend over and take it in the behind just because an officer told them too. Not everything is a law.
Dafunkdoc_Unlimited
Theological Noncognitivist Since Birth
- Joined
- Jul 25, 2012
- Messages
- 44,668
- Reputation
- 8,104
- Daps
- 121,557
- Reppin
- The Wrong Side of the Tracks
hustlemania said:again..
being detained for..?
Failure to comply.
hustlemania said:
My dad's a retired police officer. I'm pretty cognizant of my rights. I'm also VERY cognizant of the fact that as a 'Black' person, my ultimate goal is to spend as little time with the police as possible and avoid jail.
hustlemania said:yall probably would've put your camera down, if he said so too
We'd be home or where we were going in 15-20 minutes while your ass would be mad sitting in a holding cell waiting to get bailed out for HOURS/DAYS.
Data-Hawk
I have no strings on me.
She was not wrong for cracking her window half way, you are not required to put your window all the way down, only enough for the officer to see in the car because it was during the commission of a crime.
Where she fukked up at was when the officer ask her to step out she was being detained, she should of complied with his orders no matter how wrong it may have been.
But she was charged with battery on a law enforcement officer and resisting an officer -- one count of resisting with violence, and a second count for resisting without violence?
From watching the video how the fukk was she charged battery on a law enforcement officer and resisting an officer -- one count of resisting with violence?
Thats clearly the biggest mis-justice in this case.
I cant say for sure.. But if she started to roll the windows up while his hand was in the window...That's why she got that charge...Officer safety comes first, why stick your hands into a half-cracked window? Plus she kept moving in the car( from being on her phone to putting her hands on the steering wheel.....Put yourself in the cops shoes, you don't know if she had a weapon. Your life is on the line. Now she'll be in court multiple times, have to pay a lawyer, miss time from work..etc All because she thought she knew what the law was.
Ronnie Lott
#49erGang
Being difficult, bein a bytch and bein a smart ass is what led to her arrest.
she did nothing wrong..
Illuminatos
#OVOXO
Watched too many "Am I being detained?" videos.
BlvdBrawler
Superstar
This.
She isn't legally required to roll down the window.
Once he said, "You're being detained." she is legally required to get out of the car.
SouthernBelle
#Feyonce
This I can agree with. The whole being "detained" thing is bs and he only did it because his ego was bruised. However, at that point she should have complied. It would have made her complaint/case much stronger.
DWB?