Kenny West
Veteran
Oh you had one of those accidentally evil playthroughs lol. At least you got Minthara. I love listening to her talk with that haughty ass voiceI feel like with a lot of games you want to experience everything in your first playthrough, but BG3 is a rare game that's good enough and has enough to play through more than once.
Even missing content, I was able to hit level 12 easily and the game went on forever. With ~10 companions and only 3 party slots, it's fine to pick and choose as long you commit to the 2nd playthrough.
1st playthrough Me, Shadowheart, Minthara, Gale/Astarion
2nd playthrough Me, Lae'zel, and a mix of cleric hireling/Wyll/Gale/Jaheira/Halsin
The only content I won't see is Karlach's, just don't care about her or like playing with barbarians.
As far as Karlach goes, keep in mind you can always respec and change her class to something else via Withers. Admittedly her companion stuff is pretty much the least plot relevant