Aaron Rodgers Is Already The GOAT. There Are No Arguments To Be Made Against It.

JLova

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
59,082
Reputation
4,372
Daps
178,177
Horrible assessment of Peyton Manning. Dude made a Super Bowl with the worst run defense one year and a close to last running game. There's more to Peyton than what you are giving credit to.

It's amazing the level of hate Peyton gets.
 

dh86

Superstar
Joined
Jun 4, 2013
Messages
23,664
Reputation
930
Daps
53,509
Reppin
Detroit
Horrible assessment of Peyton Manning. Dude made a Super Bowl with the worst run defense one year and a close to last running game. There's more to Peyton than what you are giving credit to.

Bob Sanders played one game then came back for the playoffs in 06. Nice try tho.
 

Champ_KW

Superstar
Joined
May 12, 2012
Messages
6,516
Reputation
1,060
Daps
19,429
Reppin
NULL
Bob Sanders played one game then came back for the playoffs in 06. Nice try tho.

:stopitslime:did you even realize what you just typed??? While Bob Sanders was out Peyton went 12-4, 4,300+ yards, 31 td's, and his career low 9 ints. Nice try tho.
 

dh86

Superstar
Joined
Jun 4, 2013
Messages
23,664
Reputation
930
Daps
53,509
Reppin
Detroit
:stopitslime:did you even realize what you just typed??? While Bob Sanders was out Peyton went 12-4, 4,300+ yards, 31 td's, and his career low 9 ints. Nice try tho.

Colts had a good defense which carried them to the title while Peyton turned happy feet in the playoffs per usual
 

Jplaya2023

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
42,357
Reputation
-384
Daps
87,586
He needs to win a couple more rings (which I think he will), but his skillset alone has to put him in the conversation.

Aaron rodgers won't be another SB as long as MM is coaching this team.

Pats win the SB this year and next
 

No1

Retired.
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
30,547
Reputation
4,838
Daps
68,304
yeah, he just better than Montana.
My thing with Rodgers, and as the original A Rod advocate I feel comfortable saying this, is that he doesn't have signature wins against elite defenses in the playoffs. That Steelers d was ok. He struggles against the same teams every other elite QB does and yet people act like there's an enormous gap between him and the next guy. There's not in the elite group..there is not. He is the most talented QB I have ever seen, but you cannot just prop him one guys with more impressive overall resumes just because he has the best stats in the most offensive-minded era in football history. Montana would tear up this league too. Rodgers cannot be put over those guys with one good playoff run on his resume.
 
Top