Aaron Rodgers Is Already The GOAT. There Are No Arguments To Be Made Against It.

[FAH1223]

 

[FAH1223]

Can't be the goat anything with 1 title...

Best in the biz right now...but overall...I don't even have him in the conversation with Montana and Brady...

I mean...is this guy going to win more titles than Eli Manning?

He at least has a title

I mean, come on. Winning the Super Bowl isn't an individual feat.

 

[Basaglia]

thats a sice

Especially the Elway part

Rodgers has the best int% in NFL history and he doing it in cold ass Wisconsin. And he doing it behind a crap O-line and Eddy Lacy isnt an elite RB.

SO FAR...quess who second? and do i need to talk about all the weapons tom ain't had most of his career?

Cunningham had the GOAT WR corps in 1998 also.

What Rodgers is doing, no one has ever seen. Im confident in saying that and the numbers back it up.

and i'm saying i don't agree and can back it up with postseason sample-sizes where stakes were much higher, adding to the value of the performance of the QB.

like @Frump just said, Rodgers does NOTHING wrong.


in a big game im going with Otto Graham.

The "big game" argument is bunk. Especially since Rodgers playoff numbers are pretty close to his regular season numbers.

he's had bad games in the playoffs, just like every other great QB.

 

[Bboystyle]

This is the first time I've ever witnessed aesthetics being cysed above actual achievement. Nyggas must REALLY hate Tom Brady, because now that Peyton is washed (in terms of being a SB threat, he can still pad his stats at a high level, of course), the movement to call Rodgers the GOAT is underway.

I thought #4 would end this. Maybe 6 will.

Prolly not tho.

Rings have nothing to do with how great a player is. Rings is a team accomplishment. U really think just because Marino didn't win a ring that he should be discredited? barry sanders is my all time favorite running back yet he wasn't so great in the playoffs and he didn't win a ring. Based off is skills only, no one is seeing Rodgers. I keep telling nikkas to use their eyes but they don't listen

 

[duckbutta]

He at least has a title

I mean, come on. Winning the Super Bowl isn't an individual feat.

True...but if you are being touted as the GREATEST QB EVER...then you should be good enough to win at least 2...

Like...name one other athlete who is considered...even in discussion...for GREATEST EVER...with one title..?

The greatest ever doesn't lose to Green Bay in the playoffs last year with Russel Wilson being concussed 70% of the game...

The greatest ever doesn't need a blown call to beat the swagboyz at home to get to the NFC championship game in the first place...

Once you factor in that Aaron plays in probably the most underachieving division in sports...Stafford has NEVER beat a team on the road that had a winning record...The Vikings best QB's in the last 8 years was a washed up Favre and rookie Teddy B...The Bears are a mess...it's really quite......that he has only played in one superbowl...

 

[Bboystyle]

Can't be the goat anything with 1 title...

Best in the biz right now...but overall...I don't even have him in the conversation with Montana and Brady...

I mean...is this guy going to win more titles than Eli Manning?

Here we go with the retarded ring argument. Might as well throw Dan Marino in the bushes who is better then both qbs u nentioned

 

[Frump]

Rings have nothing to do with how great a player is. Rings is a team accomplishment. U really think just because Marino didn't win a ring that he should be discredited? barry sanders is my all time favorite running back yet he wasn't so great in the playoffs and he didn't win a ring. Based off is skills only, no one is seeing Rodgers. I keep telling nikkas to use their eyes but they don't listen

Yeah until Rodgers Marino was the best qb I've ever seen physically he just happened to play in a era of all time great teams.

If he played in this era of parity where if you have a great qb regardless of the team around him you're gonna contend every year he'd have a few titles

 

[Bboystyle]

True...but if you are being touted as the GREATEST QB EVER...then you should be good enough to win at least 2...

Like...name one other athlete who is considered...even in discussion...for GREATEST EVER...with one title..?

The greatest ever doesn't lose to Green Bay in the playoffs last year with Russel Wilson being concussed 70% of the game...

The greatest ever doesn't need a blown call to beat the swagboyz at home to get to the NFC championship game in the first place...

Once you factor in that Aaron plays in probably the most underachieving division in sports...Stafford has NEVER beat a team on the road that had a winning record...The Vikings best QB's in the last 8 years was a washed up Favre and rookie Teddy B...The Bears are a mess...it's really quite......that he has only played in one superbowl...

Easily the dumbest post on here. Rodgers threw for three hundred yards and three Td's against Dallas and win yet ur using a biased argument against him


And nikkas wonder why we cNt take Dallas fans serious on here

 

[duckbutta]

Rings have nothing to do with how great a player is. Rings is a team accomplishment. U really think just because Marino didn't win a ring that he should be discredited? barry sanders is my all time favorite running back yet he wasn't so great in the playoffs and he didn't win a ring. Based off is skills only, no one is seeing Rodgers. I keep telling nikkas to use their eyes but they don't listen

There is a huge difference between being discredited and being "the greatest ever"

Is Marino "one of the greatest" Qb's ever...absolutely...

Is he the undisputed "greatest qb ever"...absolutely not...seeing as how other QB's who are every bet as good and accomplished as him as a passer...like Brady and Montana...have multiple superbowls to go along with their stats, that are at least comparable to marino...and marino doesn't have any superbowls...making him incomparable to Brady and Montana

 

[I AM WARHOL]

Gotta have more hardware.

He has all the physical tools abs skills to someday be the GOAT but he needs more rings

 

[Bboystyle]

@duckbutta

How u gonna talk about shyt divisions when yall play in the nfc east

 

[ThiefyPoo]

Dude is amazing to watch .

As a packer fan his growth is unreal

 

[mastermind]

SO FAR...quess who second? and do i need to talk about all the weapons tom ain't had most of his career?

has Rodgers?

his #1 WR blew his knee out in the preseason and its forgotten because of how good Rodgers has been. Rodgers makes his talent look better than it is.

and imma Brady stan too.

and i'm saying i don't agree and can back it up with postseason sample-sizes where stakes were much higher, adding to the value of the performance of the QB.

Rodgers numbers are better than Brady's in the postseason

he's had bad games in the playoffs, just like every other great QB.

Rodgers has only really had two bad playoff games. That game against the Giants and the injury riddled game against the Seahawks.

 

[Bboystyle]

There is a huge difference between being discredited and being "the greatest ever"

Is Marino "one of the greatest" Qb's ever...absolutely...

Is he the undisputed "greatest qb ever"...absolutely not...seeing as how other QB's who are every bet as good and accomplished as him as a passer...like Brady and Montana...have multiple superbowls to go along with their stats, that are at least comparable to marino...and marino doesn't have any superbowls...making him incomparable to Brady and Montana

Marino was and still is regarded as the goat depending so I have no idea what ur talking about

 

[Frump]

Yeah Rodgers has time and time again made mediocre wr's into stars. These dudes who were no 1 wr's with him all leave and fall off the face of the earth