Aaron Rodgers Is Already The GOAT. There Are No Arguments To Be Made Against It.

Floyd Pinkerton

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Mar 29, 2014
Messages
7,642
Reputation
1,680
Daps
22,183
Thinking Brady is the the goat automatically makes you a trash poster in my book:umad:

:francis: Add poor reading comprehension to the list. I've never stated anything of the sort.

:sas1: The funny thing is, I completely agree with your assessment of Aaron Rodgers' playing style and skill set, and I think he's at this point quite clearly the best QB in the league (arguably has been for a couple years now). People tend not to appropriately contextualize his passing stats; Rodgers attempts a shockingly low number of passes per game, and yet he still puts up gaudy numbers. Clearly this speaks to his otherworldly level of efficiency.

He is more than capable of taking the GOAT status should he be fortunate enough to maintain good health and his numbers continue on this trajectory, but to anoint him now, over guys like Brady when his career isn't complete and he only has the 1 SB victory is simply laughable... thus, the neg/dap-undap/1-star trifecta that you so richly deserve.

Any other way you care to embarrass yourself? :sas2:
 

Monster

Aztec Street Soldier
Joined
Oct 9, 2014
Messages
7,479
Reputation
-8,615
Daps
8,156
:francis: Add poor reading comprehension to the list. I've never stated anything of the sort.

:sas1: The funny thing is, I completely agree with your assessment of Aaron Rodgers' playing style and skill set, and I think he's at this point quite clearly the best QB in the league (arguably has been for a couple years now). People tend not to appropriately contextualize his passing stats; Rodgers attempts a shockingly low number of passes per game, and yet he still puts up gaudy numbers. Clearly this speaks to his otherworldly level of efficiency.

He is more than capable of taking the GOAT status should he be fortunate enough to maintain good health and his numbers continue on this trajectory, but to anoint him now, over guys like Brady when his career isn't complete and he only has the 1 SB victory is simply laughable... thus, the neg/dap-undap/1-star trifecta that you so richly deserve.

Any other way you care to embarrass yourself? :sas2:

i'm talking about PURELY SKILL itt. do you agree or disagree that on PURELY SKILL Rodgers is the best?

it seems like we agree but your confrontaional stance makes me confused if we do
 

-DMP-

The Prince of All Posters
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
36,362
Reputation
9,344
Daps
113,018
Reppin
LWO/Brady Bunch/#Midnightboyz
Brady tho :francis:

But I'll.always root.for Rodgers (low key) just for the fact I saw him.sit in agony as he got passed up by hell teams before he finally got picked.

Only for him to have to.deal with that diva :smugfarve: afterwards



-DMP-
 

Floyd Pinkerton

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Mar 29, 2014
Messages
7,642
Reputation
1,680
Daps
22,183
i'm talking about PURELY SKILL itt. do you agree or disagree that on PURELY SKILL Rodgers is the best?

it seems like we agree but your confrontaional stance makes me confused if we do

No need to
Moving-the-goalposts-300x2402.jpg
breh. The OP is unclear and misleading if your intention has truly been to strictly analyze skill.

:usure:I'm confrontational? You're the one who created a thread entitled "If you don't think Aaron Rodgers is the GOAT you're wrong" then caught feelings when the negs started flying. I have let your point about Brady not making as much money being indicative of his talent level slide, even though it is completely ridiculous.

I believe what I said in the previous post about Rodgers. I also believe he runs the position as naturally as anyone I've ever seen. He basically has Peyton/Brady level field vision and anticipation, but also sneaky impressive athleticism and scrambling ability. In that sense it seems like we agree. It is still at best aggrandizing and at worst being wildly irresponsible to say he's GOAT when his career isn't complete.

You may have just been going for an attention-grabbing headline, but there is already enough yellow journalism at The Coli and you will find that threads like this typically end poorly. I speak from experience -- check my thread creation history. I've had a couple real shyt threads myself.

:yeshrug:Sorry breh, I don't know what else you want from me. Usually I don't even commit this level of time and effort to a shytty thread/post.
 

JLR Steez

Pro
Joined
Dec 22, 2014
Messages
640
Reputation
110
Daps
1,090
Reppin
RI
only on the coli can you slander a qb who just won a sb and was the mvp of the game yet he's not the goat bc he doesn't demand a high pay check lol
 

DrexlersFade

Veteran
Bushed
Supporter
Joined
Dec 30, 2014
Messages
39,846
Reputation
11,311
Daps
163,717
Rodgers is in for some trouble this year why anyone would have Tom Clement calling plays is beyond me he's fukking hideous...

Oh yeah Op is right!
 

FAH1223

Go Wizards, Go Terps, Go Packers!
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
73,757
Reputation
8,542
Daps
222,086
Reppin
WASHINGTON, DC
Rodgers is in for some trouble this year why anyone would have Tom Clement calling plays is beyond me he's fukking hideous...

Oh yeah Op is right!

Tom Clements has been working with Aaron since 2006

They both know everything McCarthy has installed.

It's not that big of a deal. Aaron already has a lot of freedom which he's earned in the last few years since the Super Bowl. He's in his prime and the reigning MVP.
 

yseJ

Empire strikes back
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
44,720
Reputation
2,567
Daps
64,364
Reppin
The Yay
Arod is a beast and hes been the best qb in the league for a bit but hes not even top 3 all time yet.

as far as goat,
walsh-montana.jpg
 

Monster

Aztec Street Soldier
Joined
Oct 9, 2014
Messages
7,479
Reputation
-8,615
Daps
8,156
Arod is a beast and hes been the best qb in the league for a bit but hes not even top 3 all time yet.

as far as goat,
walsh-montana.jpg


on a purely skill level he's already way better than montana. accomplishments montana is betterbut i'm talking skill
 

The Goodz

Banned
Joined
Aug 22, 2014
Messages
2,617
Reputation
440
Daps
6,391
Your whole debate is full of ifs and woulda coulda shoulda to be taken seriously.
 
Top