A Song of Ice & Fire by George R.R. Martin: Book Discussion Thread

[Bud Bundy]

Robb could've married the Frey daughter and had Jeyne too. Kings always had side pieces

naw he has to much honor for that.

Also he saw the way his mother treated Jon and he prob don't want that for his b*stards. Catlyan is the main reason why the Starks are no more and the north is ruled by the boltons. She lets Jamie go, treated Jon Snow like shyt so Robb is emotionally scared that he can't even fukk a girl without marrying her. And that led to that set up.

 

[Black Magisterialness]

naw he has to much honor for that.

Also he saw the way his mother treated Jon and he prob don't want that for his b*stards. Catlyan is the main reason why the Starks are no more and the north is ruled by the boltons. She lets Jamie go, treated Jon Snow like shyt so Robb is emotionally scared that he can't even fukk a girl without marrying her. And that led to that set up.

not to mention falling for that Littlefinger farce and and taking Tyrion hostage which lead to Jamie and Tywin mobilizing the first forces against the north...Ned's head was the straw that broke the Camels back.

 

[Foxmulder]

people really blaming Cat for Robb's fukkery?Marrying Jeyne and letting Theon go was the reason he lost.Then he fukking trusted Roose BoltonThen he didnt tell Edmure his plan to trap tywin.He should of traded jaimie for Sansa like cat said and marry her to the tyrell cat.he even admitted it in asos.

 

[MidniteJay]

people really blaming Cat for Robb's fukkery?Marrying Jeyne and letting Theon go was the reason he lost.Then he fukking trusted Roose BoltonThen he didnt tell Edmure his plan to trap tywin.He should of traded jaimie for Sansa like cat said and marry her to the tyrell cat.he even admitted it in asos.

Roose Bolton pretty much thanked Cripple Theon for his timing on betraying Robb too.

 

[Objection]

people really blaming Cat for Robb's fukkery?Marrying Jeyne and letting Theon go was the reason he lost.Then he fukking trusted Roose BoltonThen he didnt tell Edmure his plan to trap tywin.He should of traded jaimie for Sansa like cat said and marry her to the tyrell cat.he even admitted it in asos.

You can't blame her for Robb's fukkery but I do blame her for Eddard's downfall. I never liked her. Especially how she treated Jon.

 

[Bud Bundy]

people really blaming Cat for Robb's fukkery?Marrying Jeyne and letting Theon go was the reason he lost.Then he fukking trusted Roose BoltonThen he didnt tell Edmure his plan to trap tywin.He should of traded jaimie for Sansa like cat said and marry her to the tyrell cat.he even admitted it in asos.

Robb could have gotten winterfell back easy once he was done with the Lannisters. The Grayjoys didn't even want it. But him marrying Jeyne led to him being betrayed by the Frays which would not have happened if he just marry that fray girl and cheat on her like his pops and Robert did before him. They cheated and united a kingdom he marries a chick and loses a war and his house.

The high price of honer he should have just prepared for winter instead of indulging his tully side.

 

[Foxmulder]

Roose Bolton pretty much thanked Cripple Theon for his timing on betraying Robb too.

they were close to winning too before all the fukkery.

 

[Foxmulder]

Robb could have gotten winterfell back easy once he was done with the Lannisters. The Grayjoys didn't even want it. But him marrying Jeyne led to him being betrayed by the Frays which would not have happened if he just marry that fray girl and cheat on her like his pops and Robert did before him. They cheated and united a kingdom he marries a chick and loses a war and his house.

The high price of honer he should have just prepared for winter instead of indulging his tully side.

Exactly you the king in the northfukk whoever you want you don't gotta marry her.

 

[detroitwalt]

nikkas can say what they want about Cat but she understood them wolves better than Robb

“Any man Grey Wind mislikes is a man I do not want close to you. These wolves are more than wolves, Robb. You must know that. I think perhaps the gods sent them to us. Your father’s gods, the old gods of the north. Five wolf pups, Robb, five for five Stark children.”

To be fair Robb said he lost faith when he found out Theon "killed" his little brothers and theirs wolves didn't protect them, but still....he should've listened.

 

[Spidey Man]

There's word going around that Ned had big plans before he was dragged to King's Landing. He had his own politics but the King's Landing dirty politics was too much for him.

One of the plans mentioned in the book, was taking his bannermen and going up north to crush the wildings with the Nights watch.

 

[duck]

i'm like 80% done with book 4 now...i gotta say this one is the worst by far

maybe the greatness of the 3rd book spoiled me

but these ironmen chapters are a snooze to me, no imp chapters, no bran or rickon chapters...wtf. i do like the aria chapters and samwells chapters seem to be better than i thought they'd be ...but damn...the lack of the imp is hurting this book

and does it ever stop fukking raining in westeros? you'd figure the whole damn continent would be underwater by know

 

[Dat Migo]

Idk know Fat boy read some Barristan chapters a couple weeks ago
[TWoW Spoilers] Barristan - The Winds of Winter - A Forum of Ice and Fire

duck is a whiny fakkit

 

[duck]

Idk know Fat boy read some Barristan chapters a couple weeks ago
[TWoW Spoilers] Barristan - The Winds of Winter - A Forum of Ice and Fire

duck is a whiny fakkit

what the fukk does this have to do with a feast for crows

u a peice of shyt and i'm gunna put you on the endangered feces list if you keep talkin sideways

 

[MidniteJay]

i'm like 80% done with book 4 now...i gotta say this one is the worst by far

maybe the greatness of the 3rd book spoiled me

but these ironmen chapters are a snooze to me, no imp chapters, no bran or rickon chapters...wtf. i do like the aria chapters and samwells chapters seem to be better than i thought they'd be ...but damn...the lack of the imp is hurting this book

and does it ever stop fukking raining in westeros? you'd figure the whole damn continent would be underwater by know

I still enjoyed AFFC but yeah them Damphair and Brienne chapters had a nikka struggling. What about the lame ass Dork Star? "Men call me Dark Star, and I am of the night."..................

 

[Dat Migo]

what the fukk does this have to do with a feast for crows

u a peice of shyt and i'm gunna put you on the endangered feces list if you keep talkin sideways

first part wasn't directed at you
























fakkit