A Song of Ice & Fire by George R.R. Martin: Book Discussion Thread

downtheline

downtheline

All Star
Supporter
Joined
Aug 7, 2019
Messages
3,212
Reputation
806
Daps
8,768
Reppin
Back in the DMV
This scene really stood out. At first watch, I figured he was just being an a$$hole to Jon Snow about joining the Nights Watch.

Jamie was actually warning him, Kingsguard is pretty much the same thing. The look of frustration that he gives after Jon is still all hyped up on joining.

 
O.Red

O.Red

Veteran
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
18,074
Reputation
5,517
Daps
72,154
Reppin
NULL
downtheline said:
Im rereading ASOIAF, just read this;

"The two children could not have looked more different, him with his olive skin and straight black hair, her pale as milk with a mop of golden curls; light and dark, like Queen Cersei and King Robert."

Could Robert have actually fathered Marcella, and Cersei was just wrong? She may have forgotten to drink that liquid Plan B they used
Click to expand...
No because the story goes out of its way to remind you how strong Roberts genes are:russ:
 
jay211

jay211

Superstar
Joined
May 25, 2012
Messages
16,402
Reputation
1,563
Daps
45,605
Reppin
NULL
The one thing that House of Dragon needs to do is expand the scope. I think what was great about GOT it gave us all these different POVs and took us to different landscapes. We need more of that in HOTD.
 
O

old pig

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Nov 12, 2017
Messages
105,153
Reputation
20,336
Daps
437,743
Spidey Man said:
Was just thinking about something. If Rob married walder Frey's kid do we still get the Red Wedding? Or does Rob actually live and House Stark survive.
Click to expand...

definitely wouldn’t have gotten the red wedding but perhaps tywin comes up with another plot/scheme to kill robb stark
 
duck

duck

Bills Mafia
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
6,977
Reputation
2,043
Daps
23,696
Reppin
buffalo ny
Spidey Man said:
But who's to say he doesn't betray him anyway. The Lannisters can make a great offer, and walder has never been known for loyalty
Click to expand...
Rob was recognized as a king to the north and all their allies, so marrying him would make a frey a queen. The lannisters wouldnt be able to offer walder anything more than that
 
O.Red

O.Red

Veteran
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
18,074
Reputation
5,517
Daps
72,154
Reppin
NULL
Spidey Man said:
But who's to say he doesn't betray him anyway. The Lannisters can make a great offer, and walder has never been known for loyalty
Click to expand...
No the fukk they couldn't:mjlol: Tywin was LOSING that war and the clock was ticking on his chapter.

Keep in mind the reason Robb even had to marry the Frey girl. Frey gave Robb his soldiers that helped give him such an upper hand

Tywin was lucky that Robb was a sucka for love because if he just married the Frey girl like he was supposed to we would've been looking at Roberts Rebellion part two

Also keep in mind at this point in history the Lannisters are broke. Tywin was in debt to the Iron Bank trying to fight Robb. There was nothing to offer

And Walder had no reason to betray Robb if his daughter becomes Queen in the North and possibly of the 7 kingdoms. Nikkas don't betray nikkas just because they feel like it:mjlol: Walder really didn't do anything wrong out side of violating guest right to be honest:manny:

You talking about loyalty like Robb didn't betray Walder first. I would've killed that nikka too:mjlol:
 
duck

duck

Bills Mafia
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
6,977
Reputation
2,043
Daps
23,696
Reppin
buffalo ny
So since we can talk about the books in here, what do do u think the non book readers are gunna think when they see grrms muppet naming of the tully's in the house of the dragon thread.? Kermit and oscar, fathered by elmo...great granddaddy grover. :laff:

Idk if hbo would even display that fukkery.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top