A Song of Ice & Fire by George R.R. Martin: Book Discussion Thread

[Cheesy]

They fukked up even making it the brotherhood or insinuating that it was lem lemon cloak. Could have just been any run of the mill outlaws or even the mountains old crew just to add to the hound's hate of his brother. I hope they have a good reason and that it isn't just lazy writing to appease some show watchers.

This, the bwb is supposed to be all about the smallfolk, iirc they even mentioned the burning down of septs as one of the crimes they fight against. They tried to play it off with the whole 'they worship the red god' but even though they are converts, it was never established that they are zealots

 

[dennis roadman]

bwb is some broken men now brehs, they kill and loot for food and resources and for fun

it's not necessarily a bad departure from book canon

 

[beanz]

bwb is some broken men now brehs, they kill and loot for food and resources and for fun

it's not necessarily a bad departure from book canon

Nah they don't kill regular smallfolk for food and resources. They might rob em and give them a bullshyt piece of paper saying they gonna get paid back, but the only ppl they were killing were freys and lannisters. Its a huge departure to have them suddenly killing a bunch of hungry homeless religious people.

 

[dennis roadman]

Nah they don't kill regular smallfolk for food and resources. They might rob em and give them a bullshyt piece of paper saying they gonna get paid back, but the only ppl they were killing were freys and lannisters. Its a huge departure to have them suddenly killing a bunch of hungry homeless religious people.

yeah it's completely different, but not necessarily bad

 

[Adam3000]

Nah they don't kill regular smallfolk for food and resources. They might rob em and give them a bullshyt piece of paper saying they gonna get paid back, but the only ppl they were killing were freys and lannisters. Its a huge departure to have them suddenly killing a bunch of hungry homeless religious people.

That was years ago

They have spent years as outlaws. You dont expect progression?

The broken man

 

[Tasha And]

I think the actor from the show is insinuating that those brotherhood guys acted on their own, and this wasn't something sanctioned by Thoros.

But even if it was, what do you think the broken man speech is about?

 

[Chris Cool]

Yaw see this shyt? not sure if it's a spoiler because it's just speculation but

Spoiler

 

[T-K-G]

Yaw see this shyt? not sure if it's a spoiler because it's just speculation but

Spoiler

@Adam3000 gon be mad as shyt if it's true

 

[Adam3000]

@Adam3000 gon be mad as shyt if it's true

I aint worried about that shyt at all

I'm gonna be dancing in the streets on Monday asking folks "Where Syrio At?"

Extra special points if Arya uses his face, so everyone thinks he's back but gets the okie doke.

 

[Type Username Here]

That was some horrible writing.

 

[jericho]

The Tyrion/Missendei/Grey Worm scenes are painful to watch

Blackfish getting an offscreen death

 

[Objection]

I think that is the worst episode of any season. All scenes were poorly written.

 

[#StarkSet]

that fat fukk grrm really made that lady stoneheart shyt





that is stupid as fukk

 

[beanz]

b*stard bowl next week. shyt better be epic

 

[beanz]

that fat fukk grrm really made that lady stoneheart shyt





that is stupid as fukk

Its not the greatest shyt but the way it's written in the books and her reveal are dope as fukk. Gotta remember this is a fantasy genre anyway so what's another zombie .