A Song of Ice & Fire by George R.R. Martin: Book Discussion Thread

[BonafideDefacto]

Went and got my copy earlier today brehs

 

[FlyGuy]

Went and got my copy earlier today brehs

book is so crack

 

[Adam3000]

book is so crack

I dont think I give a shyt about non-Blackfyre and non-Rhaegar era Targaryen history though. Struggling through these chapters. Should just skip them and come back later

 

[FlyGuy]

I dont think I give a shyt about non-Blackfyre and non-Rhaegar era Targaryen history though. Struggling through these chapters. Should just skip them and come back later

idk it's been a great read to me so far, but I have a thing for insignificant bullshyt.

There's a Ser Elmo Tully and a Lord Kermit Tully

 

[Adam3000]

Ok, this Targ shyt is finally getting good now that I made it to Daeron. I think it is just the period from post- Aegon the Conquerer up to the Dorne conquest that bores me. The Dance of Dragons does not interest me at all.

This Baelor chapter


Dorne murdering Daeron during a peace negotiation you Dorne stans got some explaining to do for this Walder Frey type bullshyt

 

[Adam3000]

One paragraph into the Aegon the Unlikely chapter and we finally find out why Bloodraven was sent to the Wall



Plus we find out who Olenna Tyrell was engaged to which was new info the show brought up that was unclear whether or not to be book canon until now

 

[FlyGuy]

One paragraph into the Aegon the Unlikely chapter and we finally find out why Bloodraven was sent to the Wall



Plus we find out who Olenna Tyrell was engaged to which was new info the show brought up that was unclear whether or not to be book canon until now

Bloodraven took that sentence like a champ.....had his own peoples commit to life on the wall for him. That's probably how he won that LC vote

 

[Adam3000]

We are being given the framework for a bunch of future Dunk & Egg stories too

3rd Blackfyre Rebellion
4th Blackfyre Rebellion
Dunk vs. The Laughing Storm
Jenny of Oldstones woods witch prophecy (maybe?)
War of the Ninepenny Kings EDIT: nevermind, this occurred after Summerhall
Summerhall (the finale)



Unfortunately, I think GRRM may be coming to grips that he will never have time to finish all his D&E tales, which ia why we are being given the 'endings' now


Please write the Summerhall one George so it can be published posthumously if necessary

 

[FatherSimp]

Robb had too much bytch made Tully blood in his body. That's the short and precise answer.

They still ain't have to do the Young Wolf like that though

R.I.P Robb and Grey Wind

 

[Type Username Here]

They still ain't have to do the Young Wolf like that though

R.I.P Robb and Grey Wind

There is only one true young wolf and it's a she.

 

[FlyGuy]

There is only one true young wolf and it's a she.

don't forget about Rickon, the Wild Wolf

 

[Type Username Here]

don't forget about Rickon, the Wild Wolf

He ain't bout that life yet.

 

[FlyGuy]

He ain't bout that life yet.

Yet.

 

[Adam3000]

He ain't bout that life yet.

:whatthehell:


How can you be enlightened enough to be on that Robb Tully train but not on the Unicorn Killa Rickon train?

 

[DA_LURKA]

He ain't bout that life yet.

Cannibals, Unicorns, and Direwolves .