A Song of Ice & Fire by George R.R. Martin: Book Discussion Thread

MidniteJay

無敵
Supporter
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
24,456
Reputation
5,637
Daps
64,929
Alright brehs, say you're a lord of a House that was eating good under the Mad King and then Robert's Rebellion breaks out. You know that the King was crazy and that Stark and Baratheon had legit reasons to raise banners against him.

Who you fighting for?

Mad King?

Stay Neutral? (you're not an overlord/warden so staying neutral might get some other houses angry at you and shyt won't look good once there's a victor)

King Robert?
 

The Prince of All Saiyans

Formerly Jisoo Stan & @Twitter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
63,959
Reputation
7,554
Daps
109,119
Alright brehs, say you're a lord of a House that was eating good under the Mad King and then Robert's Rebellion breaks out. You know that the King was crazy and that Stark and Baratheon had legit reasons to raise banners against him.

Who you fighting for?

Mad King?

Stay Neutral? (you're not an overlord/warden so staying neutral might get some other houses angry at you and shyt won't look good once there's a victor)

King Robert?
King Robert:salute:
 

Piff Perkins

Veteran
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
50,676
Reputation
18,570
Daps
275,707
we don't know how they'll handle next season, and the timeline from the 4th and 5th books
Nah they're pretty much done with her AFFC story already. Maybe one or two eps of LF butting heads with Royce but that's about it. Bran is also gonna be done this season.
 

T-K-G

Veteran
Joined
May 12, 2012
Messages
36,685
Reputation
5,284
Daps
105,264
Reppin
LWO/Starkset
Alright brehs, say you're a lord of a House that was eating good under the Mad King and then Robert's Rebellion breaks out. You know that the King was crazy and that Stark and Baratheon had legit reasons to raise banners against him.

Who you fighting for?

Mad King?

Stay Neutral? (you're not an overlord/warden so staying neutral might get some other houses angry at you and shyt won't look good once there's a victor)

King Robert?
im not "siding" with any lord, im gonna be on my Howland Reed shyt and just hold my nikka Ned down :manny: whoever he got problems with, i got problems with :birdman:
2505dhy.jpg
 

daze23

Siempre Fresco
Joined
Jun 25, 2012
Messages
31,779
Reputation
2,681
Daps
43,697
Nah they're pretty much done with her AFFC story already. Maybe one or two eps of LF butting heads with Royce but that's about it. Bran is also gonna be done this season.
"nah" what?

I'm sayin they have a lot of content to cover, so it's not like they'll have, or need, a lot of time to advance Sansa and/or LF's story. it's already to the point on the show where they can't really cram all the current characters' story lines into one episode, and that will only get worse as we move on. I imagine that's part of why GRRM choose to split up the 4th and 5th books like that: there's a lot going on with different characters in different places. again, we don't know how the show will handle this
 

Arianne Martell

"Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken"
Supporter
Joined
Jan 22, 2014
Messages
6,909
Reputation
942
Daps
23,647
Reppin
House Martell #SnakeGang #Targset
Alright brehs, say you're a lord of a House that was eating good under the Mad King and then Robert's Rebellion breaks out. You know that the King was crazy and that Stark and Baratheon had legit reasons to raise banners against him.

Who you fighting for?

Mad King?

Stay Neutral? (you're not an overlord/warden so staying neutral might get some other houses angry at you and shyt won't look good once there's a victor)

King Robert?

Mad King :stopitslime:
 

Peter Parker

Superstar
Joined
Jan 20, 2013
Messages
8,377
Reputation
1,154
Daps
29,630
Alright brehs, say you're a lord of a House that was eating good under the Mad King and then Robert's Rebellion breaks out. You know that the King was crazy and that Stark and Baratheon had legit reasons to raise banners against him.

Who you fighting for?

Mad King?

Stay Neutral? (you're not an overlord/warden so staying neutral might get some other houses angry at you and shyt won't look good once there's a victor)

King Robert?
Depends on who I'm closer with, if I'm actually friends with the Targs then yeah I'm going Aerys, but if I got no love for them, i'd just wait to see who's winning then jump in
 

Black Magisterialness

Moderna Boi
Supporter
Joined
May 23, 2012
Messages
19,206
Reputation
4,030
Daps
45,938
we don't know how they'll handle next season, and the timeline from the 4th and 5th books

Remember though this is damn near the end of Sansa's arc in the book...and they can't just have no Sansa for an entire season. If they gave Ramsay and Theon time in season 3 they can give some time to her. At this point i have no idea what they can do seeing as how in the books no one knows her identity yet.
 

Jello Biafra

A true friend stabs you in the front
Supporter
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
46,184
Reputation
4,912
Daps
120,859
Reppin
Behind You
My reply to @T-K-G from the show thread showing how I would have kept Oberyn alive:

Tyrion's storyline could be slightly changed to his being exonerated through Oberyn winning the trial by combat but knowing that Cersei will have him killed anyway, Jamie and Varys set it up for Tyrion to secretly get out of King's landing without Cersei finding out. The rest of Tyrion's story can play out exactly like in the books from Jaime confessing about Tyrion's first wife not being a whore and that Tywin forced Jamie to lie to Tyrion which leads to Tyrion turning on Jaime to him then finding Shae fukking Tywin and killing his father in a rage thus becoming a wanted man again.

Oberyn could have been shown to have sustained some injuries in the fight with the Mountain that precluded him from killing Tywin himself. Oberyn's character could then become a merged character with his brother from the books. Say Doran dies of some illness and Oberyn becomes the new ruler of Dorne which then makes him have to leave the Small Council and King's Landing in a hurry before he can kill Tywin himself...with season 5 featuring a bumped up presence of Dorne in the show then it becomes very easy to just have all of Prince Doran's storyline from the books be carried out by Oberyn with the excuse for Oberyn not going after the Lannister's himself being because he has accepted the responsibility of the ruler of Dorne and his temper needs to be controlled. So then Oberyn becomes the one plotting against the Lannisters and wanting to align with Dany so she can claim the Iron Throne.
 

Pifferry

blegh
Joined
Nov 18, 2013
Messages
6,084
Reputation
-5,710
Daps
7,865
My reply to @T-K-G from the show thread showing how I would have kept Oberyn alive:

Tyrion's storyline could be slightly changed to his being exonerated through Oberyn winning the trial by combat but knowing that Cersei will have him killed anyway, Jamie and Varys set it up for Tyrion to secretly get out of King's landing without Cersei finding out. The rest of Tyrion's story can play out exactly like in the books from Jaime confessing about Tyrion's first wife not being a whore and that Tywin forced Jamie to lie to Tyrion which leads to Tyrion turning on Jaime to him then finding Shae fukking Tywin and killing his father in a rage thus becoming a wanted man again.

Oberyn could have been shown to have sustained some injuries in the fight with the Mountain that precluded him from killing Tywin himself. Oberyn's character could then become a merged character with his brother from the books. Say Doran dies of some illness and Oberyn becomes the new ruler of Dorne which then makes him have to leave the Small Council and King's Landing in a hurry before he can kill Tywin himself...with season 5 featuring a bumped up presence of Dorne in the show then it becomes very easy to just have all of Prince Doran's storyline from the books be carried out by Oberyn with the excuse for Oberyn not going after the Lannister's himself being because he has accepted the responsibility of the ruler of Dorne and his temper needs to be controlled. So then Oberyn becomes the one plotting against the Lannisters and wanting to align with Dany so she can claim the Iron Throne.
But what about FrankenMountain :comeon:
 

Jello Biafra

A true friend stabs you in the front
Supporter
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
46,184
Reputation
4,912
Daps
120,859
Reppin
Behind You
But what about FrankenMountain :comeon:
WIll we get FrankenMOuntain though? Some of the more absurd stuff from the book tends to get the bushes treatment on the show. We still don't know if Lady Stoneheart is going to appear. Cold Hands is not looking likely. They even dissed Strong Belwas which still pisses me off.
 
Top