djthegreat88
Superstar
So yall just gonna ignore this question?
Selmy and jorah give her lots of subtle hints but never tell her directly
A Song of Ice & Fire by George R.R. Martin: Book Discussion Thread
- Thread starter Microfracture
- Start date
-
- Tags
- books game of thrones
Selmy and jorah give her lots of subtle hints but never tell her directly
threw my book across the room... nikkas will
when they see it on the tv show cause Robb is way more likable on the show than he was in the books...
Oh ok. I'm just tired of her negative Usurper talk and how all the people the rose against her father (when they had a legit reason to) are traitor scum.
I've seen people make statements like this before and it never makes sense. Why wouldn't/shouldn't Dany thing Robert, Ned and them were usurpers? Some of y'all need to actually think of things from the character's perspective instead of your own. If Dany had all the information I'm sure she wouldn't look at her father with the same reverence and would disagree with some of the things he did, but she's still a Targaryean and would take their side. And Robert did usurp the throne.
Yeah, from Dany's POV it would make sense that she hates Robert calls him userper and all that Jorah as well. He was exiled by Roberts warden of the North, her dad was killed by the current Lord Commander of the Kingsguard, her oldest brother killed by the king at the time, and assassins were sent at her head.
I'd hate that nikka too.
I just kinda sat there with a stunned look on my face and had to put the book down for a while. Just the utter ether GRM threw to 2 of his main characters and their crew had me like
. Craziest shyt Ive read in a book
I do see it from her perspective and I know all that. I'm just stating I get annoyed with it.
Microfracture
Real G's move in silence
Arya got knocked out the chapter right after the Red Wedding. If Martin killed her I probably would've stopped reading for a while 
Uptown WaYo87
HARLEM/BX
i still remember after i read the red wedding, i put my phone down (kindle app 
) for at least 1 hour and was just staring at the wall thinking about what the fuk just went down. 
i cant wait to see this go down on tv and see peoples reaction
) for at least 1 hour and was just staring at the wall thinking about what the fuk just went down. i was shocked and pissed off at the same time, i was feeling happy for arya thinkin shes finally gonna reunite with her fam and then the author just squashed any type of hope.
Then i remember feeling bad as hell for catelyn, im like damn from her perspective her husband and entire family are killed and her oldest son is getting murdered right infront of her eyes. Besides theon, no one in the books suffered more than her
Then i remember feeling bad as hell for catelyn, im like damn from her perspective her husband and entire family are killed and her oldest son is getting murdered right infront of her eyes. Besides theon, no one in the books suffered more than her
i cant wait to see this go down on tv and see peoples reaction
Skilltastrophy
Mizzou Mafia
i was shocked and pissed off at the same time, i was feeling happy for arya thinkin shes finally gonna reunite with her fam and then the author just squashed any type of hope.
Then i remember feeling bad as hell for catelyn, im like damn from her perspective her husband and entire family are killed and her oldest son is getting murdered right infront of her eyes. Besides theon, no one in the books suffered more than her
I feel sorry for her to an extent...but Cat's brought so much of it upon herself with stupid decisions and terrible judgement that it's hard to feel for her too much
but...as I've already said...if GRM decides to end Arya...we gone have issues
Arya got knocked out the chapter right after the Red Wedding. If Martin killed her I probably would've stopped reading for a while
Yeah I thought Arya was dead at that point. If I remember correctly, it ended with some "..and everything turned to black" shyt. I thought the end of her chapter was the end of her chapter.
Sandor Clegane
labelplant
Wilt Chamberlain
Hound is so much more 
in the books than series
in the books than series
I don't want to say I predicted, but I felt all the major deaths coming like a page before they happened so that kind of took away the full impact. I could sense Joffrey was gonna screw Ned over. The way Walder Frey was acting all cool about what Robb did, the way Cat kept noticing Black Walder acting funny and the way the author made a point to mention the guest right made me know something was going down.
Renly's death is really the only one that surprised me just cause it happened so suddenly. Also Jon Snow's cliffhanger. Varys murking Kevan Lannister came out of nowhere.
Renly's death is really the only one that surprised me just cause it happened so suddenly. Also Jon Snow's cliffhanger. Varys murking Kevan Lannister came out of nowhere.
Roger Sterling
Senior Alias
As soon as Catelyn made it an issue to ask for food it was obvious what was gonna happen, yeah.
-edit. Renly's was surprising? After Mel birthed the shadow? Also wasn't expecting Snow to get Julius Caesar'd like that.
