so the only way Johnny being black is acceptable would be to have him black in the comics
On the issue of race and casting in Superhero movies...
By
Thomas Cunningham IVon July 21st, 2013 at 8:50pm· 2k saw this· 21+ people are talking
Much has been made of the rumors of cross racial casting for
Johnny Storm in the forthcoming
Fantastic Four reboot. Some have even raised the issue of casting mixed race actors (with wide crossover appeal) like
Dwayne Johnson and
Vin Diesel in roles created for more obviously(?) black actors. Inevitably, comments include some variation of,
"Well how would you feel if
Black Panther was played by
Chris Evans?"
SIGH. Notwithstanding the fact that
it's already happened in
Spawn, let's unpack that argument a little.
The old school superhero universes were a decidedly white, male club. In fact, the default expectation was that the characters would be white. So much so, that their whiteness wasn't even a consideration (until White Supremacy and other race hatred emerged as an actual motivating factor) in later years. If a title character was introduced, he (or rarely she) was white.
When
Marvel started to introduce african-american characters, they were written with race in MIND.
Power Man? He was LITERALLY a blaxploitation street smart tough guy with a heart of gold. One might consider him a version of
DC's
Wildcat with super strength and impenetrable skin.
Storm? She was an African (American) mutant weather goddess, specifically created for
Dave Cockrum's new vision of a rainbow hued
X-Men team (nothing like doubling down on prejudice against Minority Mutants).
Brother Voodoo is another example of a character where their ethnic background is integrated into the core of their character.
And let's not forget
Black Panther... A character so specifically designed to be inspirational that an entire country of super-smart, wealthy, advanced black people was introduced right along with him.
(Side note: Similarly, the Japanese Sunfire, the native tribesman Thunderbird, Russian Colossus, Irish Banshee and (to a lesser extent) Wolverine all had cultural traits as major character points.)
On the other hand, there are characters who benefitted from societal trends, but whose race is less important. These are characters who shattered the default notion of whiteness and are just guys who happen to be black.
Of these,
Falcon (
Bucky's dead, let's give
Captain America a black sidekick!) and
War Machine (Hey, why not make
Tony Stark's marginally black buddy a superhero?) are the best examples. Did
War Machine really have to be black? I'd argue no. There's the back and forth reparté that
Don Cheadle has boatloads of wry comedic talent, but there's no compelling script reason for his character to be black... not that played out in the movies anyway.
Sunspot falls into this category too. He was black brazilian youth, but came from a privileged family and his skin color didn't factor as much in his personality as his socio-economic status (this was pushed a little more aggressively during the
New Mutants interactions with the
Hellions).
Lastly, and most rare, are the characters who have undergone major shifts in comic book continuity after the fact.
Ultimate Nick Fury is the best example, as the comic book character was modelled after the actor who would later come to play him in the movies. This was a calculation based in the waning importance of
Nick Fury's WWII origins. Nobody was buying war comics, he was basically an "edgier"
Captain America holdover and
Sam Jackson is cool as hell. Done and done. That they have since retro-fitted a black
Nick Fury,
Jr. into "normal" continuity is evidence that black
Nick Fury is here to stay.
So where does that leave us? I have seen enough flips and dips with comic book continuity that this notion of "abusing my childhood memories" has no traction with me. Costumes have changed, origins have been tweaked, marriages made and dissolved (I still can't believe no one has a problem with
Scott hooking up with
Emma Frost after
Jean died!), but I won't be committing
hari kari. If the changes work, they work. When they don't, the book ends, or they resurrect the old version. It's entertainment, people!
Just bear in mind, there is a difference in a comic book character who was CREATED to be a certain color/race/religion as a bedrock part of their identity and one who is incidentally a certain color by dint of the prevailing racial prejudices of the time.