It's not a bad list of games, and pretty solid for the most part. However, I wouldn't spend $10/month to play those games. I would prefer to buy them individually or wait for them to go on sale. That would be the attitude with most gamers, so again a subscription with just MS/ABK/Bethesda first party games doesn't make playstation sub to gamepass. However, they would buy the games individually which would then cannibalize subscription sales when console is main driver at the moment. So, again it doesn't make sense for them to go that route because they would end up making less revenue imo. Plus, if they lose core xbox audience then they lose a lot of money when they don't get 30% cut from microtransactions from Fifa, Madden, Apex, Fortnite, etc.