Would Peyton Manning winning a SB this year make him the GOAT without question?

[mr. smoke weed]

peyton is a gawd debatable between him and brady, I'd kill to have either on my team

 

[Jplaya2023]

Peyton is a one and done ass nikka..

There have been so many times where the Colts were 13-3, 14-2 or 12-4 and they would lose in the 1st rd.

How bout people just watch things unfold.

i 100% agree with this. Peyton seems to do better as the undrdog, not the favorite, while brady is the opposite. It's weird.

Manning gotta play brady in the divisional in which he will lose.

Tragic

 

[Brady-Carter]

nah, not not enough to remove the Matt cassel stain. even worse now that hes probably going to be out of the league.

lets not forget that every position coach, player, or GM has been successfully replaced under Belly. that includes tom brady. so what makes you Brady stans thinks he couldn't replace Brady. Again



bottom line, manning is out there being a general, avoiding rushes throwing downfield passes with pinpoint accuracy and being a tough with a bad neck.

While Brady outhere throwing 5 yards dinks from a perfect formed pocket
and throwing 5 year old girl tantrums when he doesn't have one.

the goat is define by his play not by team accomplishments.


that's why the goats are

Montana
Manning
Marino.

there really should be no debating.

God you are a awful poster. This might be the most idiotic/retarded Manning defence/Brady hate post I have ever read.

Your brain should be protesting againts your dumb ass posts. fukk, I feel dumber for even reading this nonsense..

 

[protestor]

God you are a awful poster. This might be the most idiotic/retarded Manning defence/Brady hate post I have ever read.

Your brain should be protesting againts your dumb ass posts. fukk, I feel dumber for even reading this nonsense..

Show me where im lying?

actually never mind.

this is coming from the guy who thought the pats invented the no huddle.

 

[BLAZO da GAWD]

Peyton Manning. U talkin bout that nikka with a bum record in the 'offs?
Peyton Manning. U talkin bout that nikka that has 8 one-and-dones in his career?
Peyton Manning. U talkin bout that nikka that had a 3:7 TD:INT ratio during his one and only SB win?
Peyton Manning. U talkin bout that nikka that threw a closing pick 6 in his only other SB appearance?

GOAT?

 

[Brady-Carter]

this is coming from the guy who thought the pats invented the no huddle.

What is crazy to me, is you don't even know what a awful poster you are. Dude go back and eat your chicken fingers and play with your crayons at the little kids table..

 

[Lakers Offseason]

Peyton Manning. U talkin bout that nikka with a bum record in the 'offs?
Peyton Manning. U talkin bout that nikka that has 8 one-and-dones in his career?
Peyton Manning. U talkin bout that nikka that had a 3:7 TD:INT ratio during his one and only SB win?
Peyton Manning. U talkin bout that nikka that threw a closing pick 6 in his only other SB appearance?

GOAT?

TD pass to the other team to seal the SB.

And this is y'all GOAT? that shyt is like when Webber called the TO in the championship game. Can you imagine Jordan panicking like that? Naah nikkas, GOATs don't have those types of plays in the biggest games.

 

[Colilluminati]

Brady is the GOAT.

shyt been set in stone.

 

[BLAZO da GAWD]

Brady is the GOAT.

shyt been set in stone.

perfect picture

Won't even ask u how

 

[protestor]

What is crazy to me, is you don't even know what a awful poster you are. Dude go back and eat your chicken fingers and play with your crayons at the little kids table..

wft, awful poster, I dont even care?

I post opinions, talk sht and make lame jokes, yeah and what?


you don't like my posts, go that way man.

 

[Rekkapryde]

Spygate, Vinatieri, and that season winning 11 games with Cassell will always leave a "stain" against Brady IN MY OPINION. Not saying it's right, but it is what it is.


Super Joe >>>>>

Deal Wit It!

 

[BLAZO da GAWD]

Spygate, Vinatieri, and that season winning 11 games with Cassell will always leave a "stain" against Brady IN MY OPINION. Not saying it's right, but it is what it is.


Super Joe >>>>>

Deal Wit It!

But Andrew Luck is 10-5 with worse stats then Cassell (a pro bowler mind you) had that '08 year

No mention of that tho eh

 

[Colilluminati]

perfect picture

Won't even ask u how

Its called prophecy.

That was like 8 years ago.

 

[BLAZO da GAWD]

Its called prophecy.

That was like 8 years ago.

We're not worthy

 

[Rekkapryde]

But Andrew Luck is 10-5 with worse stats then Cassell (a pro bowler mind you) had that '08 year

No mention of that tho eh

I'm not saying that Peyton is the Goat. Too many postseason chokes, but he's EASILY top 3 IMO. His team shyt the bed without him last season.