Would Peyton Manning winning a SB this year make him the GOAT without question?

[Formerly known as...]

So what happens if Brady wins the superbowl? That make him the best ever?

 

[Savior]

To me Brady will always be better unless Payton gets at least 2 more. Unless he has a playoff run like Rodgers did a few years back.

 

[Brady-Carter]

People say this often, but they never bring a great reason besides

"He calls his own plays", he flaps his arms/yells things at his oline/ recievers and well "Espn says so"

:

Don't even get me started on this fukking this manning media BS.

 

[Born2BKing]

Oh look @Born2BKing stanning ass has shown up...

We going to see Born2 come playoff time...

We'll see breh. You know you my nikka regardless though.

 

[Brady-Carter]

We'll see breh. You know you my nikka regardless though.

Oh, we cool bra. I am just stepping up my Brady stan game today.

We need this Manning Brady playoff game. The goats going at one more time.

All stanning aside. How awesome will that game be. We are witnessing greatness, yet we argue over it..

 

[FTBS]

Don't even get me started on this fukking this manning media BS.

Yeah because the media despises Brady.

 

[Born2BKing]

Oh, we cool bra. I am just stepping up my Brady stan game today.

We need this Manning Brady playoff game. The goats going at one more time.

All stanning aside. How awesome will that game be. We are witnessing greatness, yet we argue over it..

Its gonna happen breh. I can feel it in the air.

 

[Formerly known as...]

Ya and Bradshaw stats are shyt whats your point. Hence the Trent reference. We are talking about greats with the stats to back. Where the deciding facts are rings for the most part. B/c the stats are splitting hairs at this point.

And Bradshaw does not have more rings then Montana. Correct your post.

Oh, we cool bra. I am just stepping up my Brady stan game today.

We need this Manning Brady playoff game. The goats going at one more time.

All stanning aside. How awesome will that game be. We are witnessing greatness, yet we argue over it..

I agree. Denver and New England are playing equally well IMO and could go either way. Denver will probably have home field and their D is better than ours but our Offense with Gronk back will be a handful.

 

[Formerly known as...]

Yeah because the media despises Brady.

There is an air of slight hatred toward Brady, it's almost like some media folks struggle to compliment him but with Peyton he has mad love from everyone

 

[Sonic Boom of the South]

 

[Danie84]

It would be a storyline for the Manning boys.

 

[FTBS]

There is an air of slight hatred toward Brady, it's almost like some media folks struggle to compliment him but with Peyton he has mad love from everyone

Dude that's your own issue. Both dudes get thoroughly fellated pretty much unanimously. One argument that cannot be made for either man is that the media doesn't give them enough love.

 

[holidayinn21]

he already the GOAT

edit:

 

[protestor]

So what happens if Brady wins the superbowl? That make him the best ever?

nah, not not enough to remove the Matt cassel stain. even worse now that hes probably going to be out of the league.

lets not forget that every position coach, player, or GM has been successfully replaced under Belly. that includes tom brady. so what makes you Brady stans thinks he couldn't replace Brady. Again



bottom line, manning is out there being a general, avoiding rushes throwing downfield passes with pinpoint accuracy and being a tough with a bad neck.

While Brady outhere throwing 5 yards dinks from a perfect formed pocket
and throwing 5 year old girl tantrums when he doesn't have one.

the goat is define by his play not by team accomplishments.


that's why the goats are

Montana
Manning
Marino.

there really should be no debating.

 

[Formerly known as...]

nah, not not enough to remove the Matt cassel stain. even worse now that hes probably going to be out of the league.

lets not forget that every position coach, player, or GM has been successfully replaced under Belly. that includes tom brady. so what makes you Brady stans thinks he couldn't replace Brady. Again



bottom line, manning is out there being a general, avoiding rushes throwing downfield passes with pinpoint accuracy and being a tough with a bad neck.

While Brady outhere throwing 5 yards dinks from a perfect formed pocket
and throwing 5 year old girl tantrums when he doesn't have one.

the goat is define by his play not by team accomplishments.


that's why the goats are

Montana
Manning
Marino.

there really should be no debating.

Really breh? I lost brain cells reading your post. Brady winning another ring doesn't make him the GOAT but if manning does he is? fukk out of here, ol dropped on your head as a baby.