Would Peyton Manning winning a SB this year make him the GOAT without question?

[BLAZO da GAWD]

I'm not saying that Peyton is the Goat. Too many postseason chokes, but he's EASILY top 3 IMO. His team shyt the bed without him last season.

Peyton is top 3 all time without a doubt. I got Brady/Montana, then Manning

My thing is how stupid it is to bring up the Cassell thing to discredit Brady. How does that prove Brady is overrated? U replace any HOF QB with a halfway competent one and the team should not fall off so dramatically. If the colts had competency at the position last year, they would have won more than 2 games. In fact, if Orlovsky started the entire season last year, the colts would've won at least 5 or 6 games. At least

Steve Young didn't take anything away from Montana's legacy

 

[duncanthetall]

You're silly if you don't think Peyton is the GOAT already