Quotes from one of the jurors
"No one there had an intent of agreeing with the second-degree murder (charge). No one. I know that may come as a surprise,” she said. “Really, what we were struggling with was not guilty — which didn’t bode well either, because (Hayes) had some responsibility for his actions.”
“I’m sorry, you don’t go just a hair shy of three times over the legal limit and your friends don’t know,” she said. “Everybody kind of loses credibility when they’re not being truthful"
"The juror said she respected the testimony of Smith’s wife, but that “I felt like maybe a lot of her memory was more of the man that she loved, rather than the man that was there that night.”
"Meanwhile, the defense team’s biggest gamble seemed to have won some sympathy from jurors. The juror said she was surprised that Hayes decided to testify in his own defense, but she thought it helped his case.
“It gave him some humanity that we were unable to see until that point,” she said."
“I know what he was trying to say about Will’s shooting, or that he thought he saw a gun,” she said. “He was on trial for his life, so you can understand how maybe in this amount of time that he has convinced himself of that, possibly. But none of us believed that.”
"
Two were pretty adamant about acquittal. Five were on the fence, trying to work through the emotion of that and what it meant, and then the other five were (that) he was not going to walk away without consequences. That’s really how it stacked up,” she said."
“I know there were concerns that there would be some star-struck stuff. It carried no weight,” she said. “Cardell had a packed gallery, too, of people who cared and loved him as well.”
"The juror said she was initially “on the fence” about whether to convict Hayes of manslaughter. But as the hours passed and the jurors re-enacted the final moments of Smith’s life, the juror said she came to the conclusion that Smith was “complicit” in the scenario that unfurled on Sophie Wright Place, but that Hayes had also made an “extraordinarily bad decision.”
Juror in Will Smith trial: Murder charge never on table in 'gut-wrenching' Cardell Hayes deliberations