This argument makes me
everytime because of how emotional everyone gets. The truth is KD will go down as no lower than a top-3 most unstoppable offensive player in NBA history.
He can do EVERYTHING on the offensive side of the floor. And he would have dropped 40 on the Raptors had he not blew his shyt out. That is after not playing for over a month.
The whole problem is that claim still completely ignores bball IQ, mentality, and ability to respond to the demands of the moment. Sure, he can do everything....then why hasn't he?
Why is KD only 5-20 on playoff game-winners in his career, and an even uglier 1-9 in the final five seconds?
Why is it that until last year, KD had NEVER surpassed 41 points in a playoff game despite falling short every single year until he joined a 73-win team?
That's weird, right? You would think that since the Thunder were always losing in the end, that KD would have had some games where he threw them on his back and either carried them to victory or did everything possible trying. Like LeBron's 45 game against the Wizards, his 48 game against the Pistons, his 45 game against the Celtics, his 49 and 44 games against the Magic, his SECOND 45 game against the Celtics, his 49 game against the Nets, his 44 game against the Warriors, and that crazy 2018 sequence where he put up 42, 43, 44, 44, 45, 46, 46, and finally a 51 game all in a single playoff run, with at least 7 of those 8 games basically being must-win situations.
LeBron has maybe 20 classic high-scoring games that we all remember, spread out from his very first playoff series to his absolute most recent one (I didn't even count that 40-spot when they went down to the Pacers without Bosh, or the 37-point game 7 to win a ring against the Spurs, or the back-to-back 41-point games after going down 3-1 to the Warriors, or that 46-point effort against the Hawks since they were already up 2-0, or that 40-39-37 run in his first duel against D-Rose, or all those other 40-point games against the 2009 Magic and 2015 or 2017 Warriors).
Thunder Durant has none.
Now, Warriors Durant has a few big games, but he did it with the floor wide open next to two of the greatest shooters in history. Defenses are openly trying to stop Curry first and him second. And the game situations leave something to be desired. 43 against the Cavs when the Warriors were already up 2-0 and the Cavs had nearly thrown in the towel already. 45 and 50 against a way overmatched Clippers team after the Warriors had already pulled a 3-1 series lead. And 46 (on 14-31 shooting) in a loss to Houston after the Warriors were already up 2-0.....a Houston team that the Warriors ended up beating without KD on the court at all.
That's it. That's all of KD's 42+ games in his entire postseason history. 4 games with series leads against overmatched inferior teams, with Curry and Klay spreading the floor wide out.
Why is KD's scoring history so unimpressive?