Who's Better: Jadakiss vs Prodigy

[mobbinfms]

I just gotta laugh at stupid shyt like this

I neg stupid shyt like that

without havoc, theyre 6 or 7s as well.

I don't like to delve into "what if" fictional alternative history, but if P had spit additional verses over Hav's beats, that were of the quality he had on those albums, same concepts and all, both albums would be 10s. The opposite is not true.

do you dudes seriously think prodigy would be seen as elite back then if he was a solo artist?

Yes. See above.

whos arguing with me tho? nostalgia-driven mobb deep fans. lets be real, if prodigy was some new artist in 2000, 95% of yall wouldnt care. you wouldnt have even listened to those albums dog.

This is alternative fictional history. Fact is - the great solo material was great (regardless of who was listening).

rodigy had a better solo career how? HNIC had a small wave, and hes been flat-topped and clowned ever since.

Clowned? Isn't this about the music? No one was clowning Return of the Mac on the music. And that's better than any Jada solo.

 

[Walter H White]

No rapper in Yonkers is better than Prodigy, please stop. IMO he's easily top 5 rapper of all time.

 

[Truth200]

That 1-2 punch of Still Shinin and Apostles Warning

Nothing is fukking with it in Hip Hop culture.

 

[TheDarceKnight]

I neg stupid shyt like that

I don't like to delve into "what if" fictional alternative history, but if P had spit additional verses over Hav's beats, that were of the quality he had on those albums, same concepts and all, both albums would be 10s. The opposite is not true.

Yes. See above.

This is alternative fictional history. Fact is - the great solo material was great (regardless of who was listening).

Clowned? Isn't this about the music? No one was clowning Return of the Mac on the music. And that's better than any Jada solo.

By a good bit too.

Yeah, you can't rewrite history. What happened, happened. If Jadakiss made a different debut album it could've been 5 mics too. But he didn't, so Kiss The Game Goodbye is what it is. The what if stuff can go every way, but all we have to go off of is what happened.

 

[Truth200]

 

[intilectual recipricol]

Jada easy

 

[NormanConnors]

Prodigy easily, no contest

 

[MINT]

none LOL

 

[Farrinto]

If Jadakiss made a different debut album it could've been 5 mics too. But he didn't, so Kiss The Game Goodbye is what it is.

It's like watching a top sports prospect who's career never pans out. Kiss had so much potential and talent and never put it to good use on an album. I'm just glad that he gave us some classic songs and verses. I was listening to Blackout by DMX earlier and I rewinded his verse several times.

 

[Farrinto]

none LOL

Congrats on being my first neg, breh.

 

[Dettol]

lol. Prodigy better than Kiss?
Thats why I dont post on this site like that no more... Too many idiots on here.

 

[Farrinto]

lol. Prodigy better than Kiss?
Thats why I dont post on this site like that no more... Too many idiots on here.

I think a lot of people are voting on him based on their discographies.

 

[Farrinto]

No rapper in Yonkers is better than Prodigy, please stop. IMO he's easily top 5 rapper of all time.

More like top 10 to me.

 

[TheDarceKnight]

I think a lot of people are voting on him based on their discographies.

Yep. Honestly, that's how it should be too. I think it's the most fair way to compare 2 artists. if the question had been who could beat who in a battle, or who has better multis (I see you rhyme king) then that would be different. But when people compare any artists head to head, in every genre, a big chunk of what you talk about is albums.

lol. Prodigy better than Kiss?
Thats why I dont post on this site like that no more... Too many idiots on here.

It's like @Farrinto said, most of the people that voted Prodigy (including myself) are voting that way because we're looking at albums vs albums, both solo and group. If you wanna talk pure skills, or potential, that's a different discussion. But if you listen to each of their entire careers, I don't think there's much of a question that Prodigy has made the better music. It's a tough poll too. Jadakiss to me is best rapper ever to have the least impressive albums to show for it.

 

[mobbinfms]

Congrats on being my first neg, breh.

Who did you neg breh? I must have them on ignore...