Who was Bigger at their Peak: Nas or Wu Tang?

Who had the higher peak of popularity.

  • Nas

    Votes: 16 17.2%
  • Wu

    Votes: 77 82.8%

  • Total voters
    93

JayBaldacci

All Star
Joined
May 11, 2012
Messages
5,807
Reputation
850
Daps
8,505
Reppin
NULL
Which G Rap album are we talking about?

Wu Tang grew in the borough where the boss of the Gambino crime family lived, Paul Castellanno.

I'm sure they grew up around kids of mafia affiliated guys.

You can hear on the first albums that they grew up around a LOT of Italians. Listen to Torture and tell me "I'll fukkin" doesn't sound like it's being said by a wiseguy.

Which Kool G Rap album are you saying that he started saying Giancanna? Live and Let Die?

Or are you saying he was using the alias on features

Live and Let Die is the old school Cuban Linx.
 

mbewane

Knicks: 93 til infinity
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
18,524
Reputation
3,881
Daps
52,449
Reppin
Brussels, Belgium
Does anyone know the amount of records that wu tang forever sold worldwide?

All i see is U.S record sale numbers.

Wu tang forever was big worldwide. I think they cleaned up all over in Europe and Japan more than any other artist at the time did.

I could be wrong, but i bet wu outsold nas worldwide.

Worldwide Wu was HUGE. Not saying Nas didn't have his own following, but Wu is just at a whole other level. Even after the big run there was always Wu concerts (groups or individual) in Europe. And as everyone knows it exceeds hip-hop as a genre. Just two weeks ago I was at an art exhibition based on the Wu. This article is about...another one that was two years ago here in Paris.

Découvrez les photos de "Wu Lab" : la première expo consacrée au Wu-Tang

cooking-4-tt-width-1000-height-1504-fill-0-crop-0-bgcolor-eeeeee.jpg


citron.jpg
 

get these nets

Veteran
Joined
Jul 8, 2017
Messages
53,009
Reputation
14,309
Daps
199,835
Reppin
Above the fray.
Live and Let Die is the old school Cuban Linx.
outside of some songs, LALD sounded too West Coast forced for me, so I ever rocked with it tough.

Gonna go back and listen to it, but I think the mafia aliases came on later album and songs.
In many ways, you can say that it was the precursor to OBFCL thematically.
 

Methodical

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jun 16, 2012
Messages
53,576
Reputation
6,281
Daps
123,656
Reppin
NULL
Nas obviously

Keeping people's attention as a solo artist is much harder than doing it as a group

:what:

Wu-Tang Clan have 9/10 Members it's way fukking harder to keep them together, etc. Mind you, all of them have fukking talents.
 

shopthatwrecks

Certified Babble Detector Badge Number #281713
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
41,793
Reputation
9,285
Daps
108,428
Reppin
44 bricks...acre shaker
nikka snoop is global

nikka foriegn great grandmothers know who snoop is

snoop die...today...it will be bigger than pac, nipsey, biggie and jesus combine

u will find far more ppl across the world who know snoops music than u will pac

play i get around in egypt...then play got damn me drop it like its hot or hell lets get blown...bet..the iron sheik will crip walk
 

Alvin

Superstar
Joined
Dec 16, 2015
Messages
19,588
Reputation
760
Daps
25,293
Which G Rap album are we talking about?

Wu Tang grew in the borough where the boss of the Gambino crime family lived, Paul Castellanno.

I'm sure they grew up around kids of mafia affiliated guys.

You can hear on the first albums that they grew up around a LOT of Italians. Listen to Torture and tell me "I'll fukkin" doesn't sound like it's being said by a wiseguy.

Which Kool G Rap album are you saying that he started saying Giancanna? Live and Let Die?

Or are you saying he was using the alias on features
This can be seen as early as 1989 in the song "Road to the Riches" where he makes a reference to Al Pacino (who plays mobster Tony Montana in the 1983 crime drama movie Scarface)[59] – this was long before albums such as Raekwon's Only Built 4 Cuban Linx… (1995), and Jay-Z's Reasonable Doubt (1996) made such references popular.

Album wise: Wanted Dead or Alive
 

get these nets

Veteran
Joined
Jul 8, 2017
Messages
53,009
Reputation
14,309
Daps
199,835
Reppin
Above the fray.
This can be seen as early as 1989 in the song "Road to the Riches" where he makes a reference to Al Pacino (who plays mobster Tony Montana in the 1983 crime drama movie Scarface)[59] – this was long before albums such as Raekwon's Only Built 4 Cuban Linx… (1995), and Jay-Z's Reasonable Doubt (1996) made such references popular.

Album wise: Wanted Dead or Alive
Road to Riches is one of my favorite songs, but every street rapper was incorporating bits or references of scarface into their music in the crack era

I was talking about the gangster aliases. Specifically the era where lot of rappers followed the lead of Wu Gambinos song.

Which alias did G Rap adopt on the second album?
 

Alvin

Superstar
Joined
Dec 16, 2015
Messages
19,588
Reputation
760
Daps
25,293
Road to Riches is one of my favorite songs, but every street rapper was incorporating bits or references of scarface into their music in the crack era

I was talking about the gangster aliases. Specifically the era where lot of rappers followed the lead of Wu Gambinos song.

Which alias did G Rap adopt on the second album?
idk about alias I'm talking about a the mafia theme
 

TheDarceKnight

Veteran
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
29,052
Reputation
12,785
Daps
90,171
Reppin
Jiu Jitsu
Wu.

Saying otherwise is borderline crazy to me and tells me that the person wasn't actually around back then.

The earliest Wu was slightly before my time, but I was almost in high school when Forever dropped. It's hard to explain how big that time was. People wore Wu Wear clothing, everyone had the fukking Wu bird logo drawn onto their notebooks at school, everyone debated on who the best member was, and everyone could rap the whole Triumph song from front to back, and Wu was just generally a cultural phenomenon that was bigger than music. Even non rap fans would rap Deck's opening verse on Triumph. Triumph at the time was maybe only the 2nd or 3rd million dollar music video ever made. I mean c'mon...Wu took a 6 minute track of nothing but bars and made it a single with a million dollar music video out of it...who else has done that?

I never remember Nas being disliked, and If I Ruled the World was a big song the year prior, but the earth wasn't moving for Nas. Nas at his peak of popularity was probably Ether, and he was the king of hip-hop, but Wu was bigger than hip-hop in '97 and was arguably a pop act. No disrespect to Nas as he's in my top 5 dead or alive.

I remember Only Built For Cuban Linx and Liquid Swords dropped in '95 within a few months of each other. That Purple Tape and Liquid Swords time is when the hype started getting crazy and that lead up to Forever dropping was an insane time in terms of hype.

I dont think yall understand the love that white people have/had for wu tang. Wu was way bigger during their peak than Nas
All cultures, honestly. People in Asia were also crazy for the Wu. Like I said, Wu-Tang in '97 was one of the biggest things in all of pop culture. For a moment they were bigger than hip-hop, and when OP asked who was bigger at their peak, it's hard to top anyone that was bigger than hip-hop. Nas during the Ether time in '01 was HUGE, but it wasn't a worldwide event in the way that Forever was in '97.
 
Last edited:

TheDarceKnight

Veteran
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
29,052
Reputation
12,785
Daps
90,171
Reppin
Jiu Jitsu
idk about alias I'm talking about a the mafia theme
Yeah, Wu weren't the first ones to have a mafia theme, but I think Rae and Ghost were the first ones to really put it on the map on a mainstream level. The Linx album was basically a concept album (you probably know this already) about two drug guys trying to get out of the life, all the specific cocaine references, and The Killer samples and interludes, all the nicknames for every Wu member (even Nas got labeled as Nas Escobar on the back cover art) had such an impact. At the very least Linx was the first mafia, coke rap, drug dealing album that was a true 5 mic classic.

But I feel like after like 99 nobody really gave a fukk about the wu as a group at least the people I knew, I mean ghost had a run but what was really after that.

Yeah I may even say before '99. It was kind of crazy. People just kind of moved on to other things. I think in '98 when Jay dropped Volume 2 and and DMX dropped, they sort of took over the east coast scene, and Dre dropped 2001 in 1999, and Eminem was becoming popular. It didn't help that Raekwon dropped a sophomore slump and then The W was just not good. RZA started falling off as a producer and refused to let up and coming hot producers onto Wu albums. I think there was a bubble and it just burst after Forever dropped. The culture was just shifting towards different interests.

do you know how difficult it is to have 9 members in a group and to get them to put all their egos aside and come up with the music they came up with?
Yep. And honestly 10 members because looking back I think you kind of have to count Cappadonna as an official member even if they didn't officially list him until later. He was heavily involved on so many of the group albums after 36 Chambers and he was all over the first run of solos. Cap's verse on Winter Warz is arguably a top 10 verse from the entire Wu catalogue.
 
Last edited:

KENNY DA COOKER

HARD ON HOES is not a word it's a LIFESTYLE
Supporter
Joined
Jun 9, 2012
Messages
31,450
Reputation
13,285
Daps
168,511
Reppin
F
Wu was one of the first iconic brands to rise out of the 90s

that WU symbol is as legendary as the Death Row electric chair logo or the Yo Mtv rap symbol

on a global level..WU was way more popular

i remember going to the WU store on peachtree in 96 and having to wait in line to get in cause it was a gang of asian toursit kids who had invaded the spot

NAS always had a niche fan base and it pisses me off...because NAS IS MY FAVORITE RAPPER....

i wish back then people could really appreciate his art like they do now.......

ILLMATIC didn't have the impact outside of NYC that 36 chambers did...REAL FAX
 

blankstairz

Superstar
Joined
May 29, 2018
Messages
4,274
Reputation
2,080
Daps
17,790
If you are speaking commercially..just by sales....Nas.

If you are speaking impact....Wu. Plus, Wu had a big overseas following too.

Impact from a hip-hop perspective. Nas' main impact on Hip-Hop was Illmatic. Illmatic was critically praised, but the commercial success didn't match the sales of the West Coast cats and later Biggie. Nas wanted that success and aligned with Steve Stoute, Trackmasters. After that, it was a mixed bag with his studio albums. Lyrics were always on point, but his creative choices were questioned at times. At least for hip-hop heads. He didn't really come back home until Stillmatic.

Wu had Enter the 36, and the 5 solo albums (+ RZA on Gravediggaz) leading up to Forever. From 1993-1997, they could walk on water.
 
Top