“’Saving for well done’ is a time-honoured tradition dating back to cuisine’s earliest days: meat and fish cost money. Every piece of cut, fabricated food must, ideally, be sold for three or even four times its costs in order for the chef to make his food ‘cost per cent’. So what happens when a chef finds a tough, slightly skanky end-cut of sirloin, that’s been pushed repeatedly to the back of the pile? He can throw it out, but that’s a total loss…Or he can ‘save for well-done’ – serve it to some rube who prefers to eat his meat or fish incinerated into a flavourless, leathery hunk of carbon, who won’t be able to tell if what he’s eating is food or flotsam.”
I have multiple chef friends that have confirmed this for me. 4 different ones from 4 different restaurants in 3 different parts of the country (Orlando, chicago, vegas). No one who orders well done ever gets a really good steak, ever.
I was in New Orleans last year with a homegirl, We went to Emeril's Delmonico and she was about to order a $54 steak well done, and I asked the waiter to ask if the chef could come to the table and talk. I straight up asked him about how they save certain pieces for people who order well done and he laughed and admitted it. He said of course all their steaks are high quality, but they do choose which steak you get based on how cooked you order it.