Who is better Peyton or Eli?

[Boolean]

Peyton w/ Eli's defense

THANK you my nikka, dude would have been on a 7 year tear if he was as blessed as Eli was/is (aside from Freeney & Mathis fukk boys)

Eli is a better playoff performer then Marino too

what does that have to do with the overall performance of a QB tho? Dude isn't even top 3 in the league now but he's better than Marino

Eli is already one of the best qbs I've ever seen.

Damn fam, you must not have seen alot of QB's then

 

[greenygreen]

Eli is already one of the best qbs I've ever seen.

forreal this dude led a team last in rushing, most in qb pressures, 26th in defense to super bowl victory please show me another qb who carried his team like that

 

[GzUp]

forreal this dude led a team last in rushing, most in qb pressures, 26th in defense to super bowl victory please show me another qb who carried his team like that

Noticed that you signed up to the coli to say this

Green k.

 

[greenygreen]

Noticed that you signed up to the coli to say this

Green k.

been signed just never posted, always lurking tho

 

[HarlemUSA]

Yall nikkas are really hyping the Giants D went from to Who says wining doesn't change anything. The best D he had was in 2008. That boy Cweb was cold that year.

 

[mvp_status]

So the people who chose Eli are ready to rank him as a top 5 QB of all time?

Because thats where Peyton is at right now

 

[MAKAVELI25]

Lol just a year ago people questioned if the honorable Elisha was Elite

The-Coli>>>

 

[TheProfessor]

Eli not there yet. But I think he will be.

 

[NkrumahWasRight Is Wrong]

So the people who chose Eli are ready to rank him as a top 5 QB of all time?

Because thats where Peyton is at right now

peyton is not top 5 all time

 

[Pack2]

Eli doesn't even play in a Bowl without those Defenses. Peyton carried those good Colts teams
Don't get me wrong Eli is cold....as much as I hate to say it

Hypothetical....
Would the Colts have won that Bowl with Eli as the QB?
We know the the answer to, if Peyton was on the Giants

Hypothetical....if Peyton was on the giants and had to play AT Tampa, AT Dallas and AT Green Bay and then beat the Pats in the SB

THEN play AT Green Bay and AT San Fran and then beat the Pats in the SB for a 2nd time?

In both SB down in the 2 min drill needing a TD for the win you think he got it over Eli?

 

[PTBG]

stop it Peyton easily. smh Eli wasn't even a top 10 QB last season, now just cuhz he won another SB ring won't erase all those inconsistent years he had, INT after INT's. Eli is like the Olympics, its something special and great that happens ever 4 years (NH), but other than that, give me the 4-time MVP all day. Right now, probably Eli, but I got a feeling Peyton is gonna be having another killer season.

 

[BStapies]

Colts defense was very similar to giants defense of now.

shytty secondary (with exception of bob sanders)
shytty-below average linebackers
Great defensive line (Dwight freeny and Robert Mathis in their prime)

 

[HacksawJimThuggin]

Peyton is a top 5 QB of all time.


Eli will never be considered such.

 

[NkrumahWasRight Is Wrong]

Peyton is a top 5 QB of all time.


Eli will never be considered such.

name your top 5

 

[TheProfessor]

stop it Peyton easily. smh Eli wasn't even a top 10 QB last season, now just cuhz he won another SB ring won't erase all those inconsistent years he had, INT after INT's. Eli is like the Olympics, its something special and great that happens ever 4 years (NH), but other than that, give me the 4-time MVP all day. Right now, probably Eli, but I got a feeling Peyton is gonna be having another killer season.

Eli was definitely top 10 last year.