Who is better Peyton or Eli?

[HarlemUSA]

The throw right to Asante in the first SB. The two throw to multiple 9ers dbs that the nikkas crashed into each other trying to get a hold to in last years NFC title game.

I remember one of them Nicks broke his route to go that way but said and went the other way.

 

[TheProfessor]

I remember one of them Nicks broke his route to go that way but said and went the other way.

Yeah, I definitely remember that. Manningham used to have too many of those. Or he'd just straight run the wrong route

 

[23Barrettcity]

Yeah, I definitely remember that. Manningham used to have too many of those. Or he'd just straight run the wrong route

How bout how manningham was always too close to the sidelines. He beat the defender and couldn't stay in bounds

 

[TheProfessor]

How bout how manningham was always too close to the sidelines. He beat the defender and couldn't stay in bounds

I loved Mario out of Michigan - and I think he might do well in a simplified offense over in SF. But his brains (or lack thereof) and inability to go across the middle used to drive me crazy.

 

[HarlemUSA]

Yeah, I definitely remember that. Manningham used to have too many of those. Or he'd just straight run the wrong route

That's my Wrs tho

Yeah he earned my respect in 10 when we had Street FA with Smith and Nicks out/injured and he put the team on his back.

Remember when Nicks stopped running a slant route in the endzone and some bum ass player from Dallas got 100 yd TD. Nicks was like the whole time.

 

[FTBS]

Of course I look into if they ran the wrong route with other QBs. I tell ya what else doesn't reflect on him...imaginary interceptions. Simply put, you don't know who was at fault and, more importantly...they didn't happen.

As long as you are consistent with it I'm good.

 

[HookersandIceCream]

 

[Street Knowledge]

Peyton Regular season, Eli in the clutch and In the Postseason

Overall Peyton is ranked higher

..............

 

[Megatron Island]

As a Chargers fan, Eli.