What's up with people hating on "Man of Steel"?

Art Barr

INVADING SOHH CHAMPION
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
64,940
Reputation
12,730
Daps
90,994
Reppin
CHICAGO
:patrice:

why was young clark wearing a red cape and pretending to do the classic superman pose?

how could clark's mother assume this meant he had plans of being a superhero one day?

how can she say with an honest face "your father always knew".... when he basically preached the opposite to clark his entire life and even sacrificed himself to re-enforce it?

so, you overly critical of pa kent's pillow talk with ma Kent.
really,....

plus, what parts of superman's internal conflict do you not get.
when, they had a whole tv show about him being scared of being superman and flying just for starters.
the shyt you are complaining about is standard shyt in superman's origin that were addressed and closed out.
I don't get what you are complaining about you are complaining just to complain.
I don't even know what frame of reference you have for what you believe superman to be.


Art Barr
 

satam55

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jul 16, 2012
Messages
45,261
Reputation
4,903
Daps
89,169
Reppin
DFW Metroplex
Reading through some of the other threads people act like it was a bad movie, but I thoroughly enjoyed it the first time I saw it. Decent Superman, pretty interesting story, good villain, great action scenes, and they finally gave Luthor a break and let Superman actually fight somebody as opposed to just Kryptonite traps. Was certainly leagues better than the Superman movie before it.

Why do people hate on this movie? I legitimately don't get it and am curious to know. I mean it's not "The Dark Knight" or Avengers status I suppose but it's a good movie and probably the best superhero flick of 2013.
The hate for "Man of Steel" has always been Bullshyt. The fact that the movie did so well in the Box Office & Warner Bros. is building their movie universe off of it should tell you all you need to know.
 

Young Bishop

Piff Poster
Joined
May 4, 2012
Messages
105,110
Reputation
11,065
Daps
244,484
Reppin
Broward County
Man of Steel had its flaws, but what comic based movie doesn't. I thought it was entertaining enough. General Zod
and his right hand chick made the movie for me. Superman
Is one of those characters that can't win with the public no matter what is done to him. Other heroes get slight updates to fit the modern era(Spider-Man,Cyclops,Batman etc) With
Superman if you change him too much people complain. If you don't change him people complain.
 
Joined
Sep 12, 2013
Messages
11,695
Reputation
-72
Daps
29,218
Reppin
NYC
Man of Steel had its flaws, but what comic based movie doesn't. I thought it was entertaining enough. General Zod
and his right hand chick made the movie for me. Superman
Is one of those characters that can't win with the public no matter what is done to him. Other heroes get slight updates to fit the modern era(Spider-Man,Cyclops,Batman etc) With
Superman if you change him too much people complain. If you don't change him people complain.

the trailers made it very clear this was a modern take on superman. everyone was ready and everyone was excited. the movie opened huge.

it just didn't deliver for a lot of ppl.
 

KushSkywalker

Walker Lexus Ranger
Joined
Jun 9, 2012
Messages
14,980
Reputation
3,535
Daps
32,745

While the movie had flaws, I hate these types of videos

These guys get so smug by pointing out every flaw in logic in movies.

I'm pretty sure you could find these leaps in logic in virtually any movie ever created if you wanna break it down by every scene and question each word said, each motivation, and the realism of each scenario.


This guy is annoying in this video.
Like really it's too sunny and not windy enough for a tornado ? :mjlol:

You really want logical scientific explanations for every piece of technology used? :mjlol:

You gonna break down every situation where the physics are wrong?:mjlol:

Why are they throwing each other in fights? :mjlol:

Why does the enemy have metal pins for claws? :mjlol:

Why did they run into each other at the right place and the right time? :snoop: (it's a movie that's why)

Why does Superman's dad say it's nice to see him grown if he's dead? :snoop: Uhh because it's a comic book movie about highly advanced civiizlations and technology, you want them to break down how this is possible? Really?












We get it... there's holes in the plot, and issues in logic, but somehow it was still entertaining :krs:


It's an hour and a half movie and he is mad about every 'convenient' situation that occurs. As if they don't in other movies, or the comics for that matter.

Listen I get it, the plot could have been stronger, the situations could've been more carefully thought out and worked through to be more realistic, but c'mon it's a Superman movie. How serious does it have to take itself exactly?:shaq2:

I guarantee you could do this with movies the same guy considers classic too. Or any movie for that matter.

Out of that 8 minute video it was mostly nitpicking crap. :cape:

I'd like to see this guys scripts he wrote, I'm sure they are flawless.
 

Lakers Offseason

Superstar
Joined
May 21, 2012
Messages
6,373
Reputation
981
Daps
12,728
Reppin
NULL
It wasn't as bad as some people make it out to be. I could sit there and watch a few scenes when it's on TV but not the entire movie.

The pacing was horrible or maybe they just edited it horribly.
 

Poetical Poltergeist

Precise and cold hearted
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
36,940
Reputation
5,370
Daps
120,613
Reppin
Mile in the Sky
would be really cool if they found a very good christopher reeves lookalike to play superman, he just had a way better look as clark imo
:what: like they did with Superman Returns...that didn't work out so well.

It was a good action adventure, this flick has been picked apart on this board since it came out though.
 

RJY33

master of reality
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
4,075
Reputation
120
Daps
4,326
great movie. never been a big superman fan at all, but i actually bought the 3d bluray of this. superman needed a modern update and this was perfect. world isnt the same as it was from the dc comics in the 1950s. only thing im a little dissapointed in is that he isnt getting a man of steel 2 without batman, etc.
 

Ethnic Vagina Finder

The Great Paper Chaser
Joined
May 4, 2012
Messages
54,658
Reputation
2,575
Daps
154,723
Reppin
North Jersey but I miss Cali :sadcam:
While the movie had flaws, I hate these types of videos

These guys get so smug by pointing out every flaw in logic in movies.

I'm pretty sure you could find these leaps in logic in virtually any movie ever created if you wanna break it down by every scene and question each word said, each motivation, and the realism of each scenario.


This guy is annoying in this video.
Like really it's too sunny and not windy enough for a tornado ? :mjlol:

You really want logical scientific explanations for every piece of technology used? :mjlol:

You gonna break down every situation where the physics are wrong?:mjlol:

Why are they throwing each other in fights? :mjlol:

Why does the enemy have metal pins for claws? :mjlol:

Why did they run into each other at the right place and the right time? :snoop: (it's a movie that's why)

Why does Superman's dad say it's nice to see him grown if he's dead? :snoop: Uhh because it's a comic book movie about highly advanced civiizlations and technology, you want them to break down how this is possible? Really?












We get it... there's holes in the plot, and issues in logic, but somehow it was still entertaining :krs:


It's an hour and a half movie and he is mad about every 'convenient' situation that occurs. As if they don't in other movies, or the comics for that matter.

Listen I get it, the plot could have been stronger, the situations could've been more carefully thought out and worked through to be more realistic, but c'mon it's a Superman movie. How serious does it have to take itself exactly?:shaq2:

I guarantee you could do this with movies the same guy considers classic too. Or any movie for that matter.

Out of that 8 minute video it was mostly nitpicking crap. :cape:

I'd like to see this guys scripts he wrote, I'm sure they are flawless.
:umad:
 

Krispy

#FreeBigLurch
Joined
May 26, 2013
Messages
1,720
Reputation
1,380
Daps
3,446
Reppin
UK
great movie. never been a big superman fan at all, but i actually bought the 3d bluray of this. superman needed a modern update and this was perfect. world isnt the same as it was from the dc comics in the 1950s. only thing im a little dissapointed in is that he isnt getting a man of steel 2 without batman, etc.

He is, I think it's been announced for 2019
 

KravenMorehead™

Barrel Brothers.®
Joined
Nov 4, 2014
Messages
33,273
Reputation
9,740
Daps
95,429
Reppin
NoVA
http://www.theshiznit.co.uk/feature/10-dumbest-things-about-man-of-steel.php
10 dumbest things about Man Of Steel
Posted by Matt at 07:00 on 20 Jun 2013



film.gif
We've all seen Man Of Steel now, right? So I don't have to worry about spoilers? Good, in that case: IT BE STOOPID.
Generally, there has been a very mixed reaction to Man Of Steel, with as many wrong people claiming it to be the best thing ever as there are correct people claiming that it sucked Krypto The Superdog's doggy lipstick. Just to help readdress the balance then, here's a recount of dumb things that dumb Superman and his dumb friends did in the film.
1. Superman fights a special effect

ManOfSteel-Tentacles-476.jpg


As Superman leaves the people of Metropolis to fend for themselves while he flies halfway around the world to destroy a different World Engine, it suddenly grows Doc Ock-like tentacles that start attacking him. Sure, sure - alien technology can do anything you want it to, right Zack Snyder?

But, really, how does this even work? Is the machine alive? The tentacles can apparently grow to any length and basically act like they have a consciousness, so what exactly are these World Engines? Robots? Living metal alien things? What do they do when they're not terraforming other planets? WHY DOES NONE OF THIS MAKE SENSE? But yes, yes, I know – aliens. You’re right, it’s all clear to me now.
2. Hurrah! I saved Metropolis… oh wait

ManOfSteel-Buildings-476.jpg


It’s fair to say that the level of destruction experienced by the city of Metropolis reaches pretty epic proportions, but this is troubling for a number of reasons - not least because Snyder uses it as an opportunity to imitate footage captured at the time of 9/11.

No, the main problem is with the staggering death toll that this must have racked up, but is never actually mentioned - which must easily sit in the hundreds of thousands. Granted, in some cases there's not a lot Superman can do to prevent the rising kill-count, but he doesn't show a second's thought that some people might be in danger unless it's Lois herself dropping out of the sky. Genocide would be an uncomfortable fit in ANY Superman movie considering what the character is supposed to stand for, but things get seriously questionable when our moral guardian actually contributes to the destruction by throwing and punching Zod through every skyscraper in sight. What an utter krypto-douche.
3. Zod finds Earth through unequivocal SCIENCE

ManOfSteel-PhantomZone-476.jpg


Zod and his men were sentenced to the Phantom Zone for 300 cycles of something-or-rather (which, as Zod says, is pretty much a lifetime, so why didn't they just say that), but luckily their punishment is short-lived. In fact, it seems to have lasted just a couple of weeks. But then they are left unable to find Kal-El and without the means to travel anywhere to get to him.

So how did they arrive at Earth? Luckily, Zod himself provides a handy explanation for Supes, which consists of something like "Luckily we managed to retrofit the Phantom Zone to our hyperdrive". Oh right. Wait, you did the what now?
4. Perry White kills the best story he’s ever had

ManOfSteel-PerryWhite-476.jpg


Perry White proves that he has no journalistic instinct whatsoever by killing Lois Lane’s story about a kindly alien stranger. Don’t get me wrong – it's understandable that he doesn’t want to run a story in his newspaper about the laughable notion of aliens, but it HAS been researched by his best reporter Lois Lane, so you’d think he'd realise there was some merit to the story. Maybe, he could suggest some editorial changes and ask for a rewrite instead of saying a clear "No. Never. Nuh-uh".

Of course, he also hints at the same argument that Jonathan Kent had been teaching a young Clarke for his whole life: the general public just aren’t ready yet. But then, shortly after, Superman and Zod and a whole bunch of other Kryptonians make themselves known to the people of Earth anyway, so really Perry has just denied The Daily Planet the greatest scoop in the history of journalism. Wait until the paper's investors hear about this.
5. "There's only one way this ends, Kal: Either you die, or I do."

ManOfSteel-Zod-476.jpg


Already the leading contender for our inevitable 'Worst lines of 2013' feature at the end of the year due to the fact that writer David Goyer is apparently shyt at maths.
6. Flying, space-travelling aliens fight within a three-block radius

ManOfSteel-Fighting-476.jpg


The final showdown between Superman and Zod is a fast-paced battle that sees the pair using their superspeed and flight to zip across the screen at every angle, throwing each other into distant skyscrapers, dragging each other through buildings and, at one point, flying up in the air and into space. And yet they always return to pretty much the exact same spot in Metropolis. Why?

Not only does this make no logistical sense, you'd think that Superman might take any opportunity to drag his fight with Zod away to somewhere more remote so as not to endanger the lives of the people of Metropolis, not to mention Lois Lane. Y’know, that woman that he just fell in one love with a couple of hours earlier.
7. Oh, of course – a black hole!

ManOfSteel-Dialogue-476.jpg


There were some huge dialogue farts throughout Man Of Steel, but one of the best came from a near telepathic exchange between Superman, General Swanwick and military professor-type Dr Emil Hamilton when discussing how to defeat Zod. It went something like this:

Superman: "We need to use the ship to crash into the World Engine"
Dr Hamilton: "Of course, that will cause a singularity..."
General Swanwick: "... which will create a black hole!"

CONVERSATIONS DON’T WORK LIKE THIS.
8. "It’s coming in through the RSS feeds"

ManOfSteel-RSS-476.jpg


And there we have what will probably end up as #2 on our 'Worst Lines of 2013' feature, as spoken by a panicked military officer. She may as well have said "Argh! It’s on all of the internets!”
9. We get it. Superman = Christ

ManOfSteel-Christ-476.jpg


There was a lot to be said about the Christ imagery in Superman Returns but by god is this so much worse. From Jonathan Kent’s frequent speeches about Clark Kent "being sent here for a reason" and "leading the way", to his floating crucifix pose as he left Zod's spaceship, Man Of Steel has one hell of a Messiah complex. And no, I don’t think Supes specifically mentioning that he is 33 is a coincidence either.

Far from just being a little bit preachy, though, this Christ-like comparison causes several problems. The main one being that Superman is apparently going to "show us the way and guide us towards hope" and he ultimately does this by… snapping Zod’s neck? Whether or not you care that this seems out of place for the Superman character we all know, it certainly doesn’t bode well for any hero who spends the entire film learning about how he should be leading by example.
10. Russell Crowe's pet flying dragon

ManOfSteel-Dragon-476.jpg


Russell Crowe has a pet dragon on Krypton. Russell Crowe. Pet Dragon. Who thought this was a good idea?
fullstop.gif
 

Wild self

The Black Man will prosper!
Supporter
Joined
Jun 20, 2012
Messages
80,284
Reputation
11,030
Daps
216,388
A lot of people hate Superman because they can't get the campy 70s version of him out of their heads. They hate when he somehow exceeds the haters expectations and deliver something that modernized him. How can people shyt on the first American superhero and still respect the genre itself? :what:

Kinda remind me of modern rappers shytting on the pioneers of Hip-Hop because they "old" or "played out."
 
Top