Been out of anime for a couple of months. Will watch Vinland Saga and Dr. Stone eventually but I wanted to binge MHA considering they were doing by far their best arc...
It was good but fukk man, felt really disappointed with it to be honest
like every big moment was big, but it never felt as epic as it was reading the manga. Considering how Studio Bones work is, I'm confused at how they weren't able to pull this off as I thought they would.
Am I alone in this or is the general feeling from the people that knew/read the Yakuza arc one of "it was good but I expected more"?
@42 Monks @winb83 @twan83 @Mr. Negative
Its the best arc. I don't know what anyone else is talking about. Actual stakes, a real villain that's about something for a change, plenty of fights - this is the arc you read and think 'this is perfect for anime'.
They dropped the ball on everything after the first red riot fight imo. The manga had real ass dread going into that yakuza compound. Like they really had you feeling like some of these kids weren't going to make it. All Might was not coming through that door. Everyone was scared and trying to prove themselves at the same time. All of that atmosphere was gone. And Mirio? They did him dirty in the animation too.
Apparently, Bones split time between this season and the movie - which was garbage outside of the last fight. But that last fight is clearly where the animation budget was focused too.
I think that a lot of people are riding the hype off of that last fight with Deku and Overhaul. And yeah, its an AMAZING sequence. However, their one note takes on everyone being even more hollow than an already dry source material make it, like you said, kinda unsatisfying. The worst part about it all though is that it does not get better. With Attack on Titan, brehs knew that there was gonna be a pay off. Attack on Politics would end, and you'd get some huge, impactful sequences and world building. Characters who were already interesting become more interesting. Backstories fleshed out not just an event, but gave clarity and purpose to the entire world.
MHA just glosses over all that. And people try and defend it by saying its a school anime at heart and that people are growing but that's weak as hell too. The author doesn't even have the patience to draw out more than one conflict between the group at a time. Anything more complicated than "you hurt my feelings when you didn't listen" is chapters upon chapters of looping dialogue.