In the beginning the characters where well thought out, well written, and arguably better in the show. Fast forward, and characters that were memorable in the comics were shyt on the show, and the characters we thought were better on the show took a nosedive in the "i care for this character" ranking.
These Characters are A THOUSAND times better, and have more importance in the comics, no questions.
Governor
Negan
Carl
Tyreese
Andrea
Abraham
Jesus
Ezekiel
These characters are tied with the show, or a little bit better in the comics
Dayle (probably would've been better on the show if Darabont stayed)
Maggie
Lori
Rosita
Heath
Dwight (some may argue he's A Thousand times better in the comics)
Aaron
*Morgan (would have easily put him on the better in the show list, but he's become a non-role player imo. Actor is great, despite his character not doing much as of late.
And these characters are better in the show
Rick (Some may argue this)
Michonne (Some may argue this)
Shane (Thousand times better in the show)
Father Gabriel
Eugene (Show has way more fukkery with him)
Carol (Thousand times better in the show)
Glen (Only a little bit better in the show, some may argue this)
Hershel (Thousand times better in the show, tho he basically took Dayle's role)
I'm sure i'm missing some characters.
Of course plot/storylines, story arcs, pacing, dialogue etc is VERY important, but one thing these recent seasons proved to me is "A show could only be as good as it's characters, and how well they're developed."
i don't care if most of these characters die. Especially all these new nikkas. from the last 2 seasons or so.