Vick vs Mcnabb

[bxrfan]

I think it's unfair to say that McNabb had no heart. You don't do some of the things he did without having it

In only his third year he took the Eagles to his first championship game where he nearly beat the heavily favored Rams on their home turf, same Rams squad considered the "Greatest Show on Turf".

Everyone talks about T.O's heroics in the Super Bowl but McNabb suffered his own broken ankle in 2002 yet came back early to lead them to another championship game. He led that 04 Eagle team to the Super Bowl without T.O, and while McNabb could've played better in the Super Bowl he still threw for more yards in the big game than anyone besides Brady and Kurt Warner. Eagles were in that game right till the end.

Also worth mentioning is how McNabb had the Eagles climb out of a 24-6 deficit in the 2nd half of the 08 NFC championship to take the lead

He also stayed advocating black quarterbacks and constantly talked about the struggles they faced

 

[intruder]

Vick was more fun to watch. McNabb was the far far better QB. Vick could have been so much better if he had taken it more seriously by his own admission

 

[gangreen]

Amazing when TO left McNabb fell off even with young Desean Jackson and Maclin.Vick actually got better as a QB as he got older.

They made it to the nfc championship game in 08.

 

[AlbertPullhoez]

Michael Vick was garbage until he got locked up

 

[bnm8907]

McNabb his consistency just way better.

What do guys think would have happened if Vick had Andy Reid as his coach from the beginning? Reid has his flaws but he seems to be good at developing qb talent. And the year he had with Vick.