Supreme365
Superstar
Which version of Vick are we talking about....you know what fukk it maybe atl Vick could've got it done with that team
Vick vs Mcnabb
- Thread starter Supreme365
- Start date
Which version of Vick are we talking about....you know what fukk it maybe atl Vick could've got it done with that team
This is disrespectful to mcnabb who was a top 5 qb for several years. Vick had like one year which was 2010
Supreme365
Superstar
what a dumb ass question...Iverson and Vick fans are the WOAT
But I voted mcnabb
I was just tryna give youll something different from bron vs Kobe threads
Dr. Narcisse
Veteran
Vick in 2010 is better than any version of McNabb.
McNabb's career is far better than Vick's.
McNabb's career is far better than Vick's.
Better career? McNabb
Better peak? Vick
Build around? Vick only because it's probably easier to build a good offense around an top tier dual threat QB. And you can really focus on defensive personnel. But if I already had a good squad in place it would be McNabb
Better peak? Vick
Build around? Vick only because it's probably easier to build a good offense around an top tier dual threat QB. And you can really focus on defensive personnel. But if I already had a good squad in place it would be McNabb
TO was injured in the sb
Mcnabb had stimkson james trash and fred ex mitchell as his wideoits with an undersized westbrook carring the ball
PortCityProphet
Follow me to the truth
Just say you don't know shyt outside of Madden 04.
McNabb WAS the top tier dual threat QB.
Bruh just say you think all black QBs run and let's call it a day. Or say you don't know the difference between running and scrambling.
Just say you don't know shyt outside of Madden 04.
McNabb WAS the top tier dual threat QB.
McNabb was always a pass first QB. Outside of his first few seasons dude barely ran. shyt by your dumb logic Andrew Luck is a premier dual threat QB, he runs more than McNabb did.
No it's not.
Vick didn't have a better peak, but that's only because he got cheated out of his prime physical years.
I'm a lifelong Eagles' fan grew up in Philly, I watched McNabb's whole career, and saw the whole 2010 season with Vick. Vick was the most dynamic and exciting QB probably ever, but McNabb was a superior player and reached a higher peak than Vick did.
McNabb had 1 good receiver his whole career and that only lasted 1 season, in 2010 Vick had DJack, Maclin and Lesean McCoy, a prime McNabb with those weapons probably would've won a Super Bowl.
Rocket Scientist
Superstar
Eagles Defense was among best those years.Westbrook helped Eagles out alot as well.TO was injured in Super Bowl and still did his thing.Mcnabb almost led a game winning drive until he threw up and Harrison caught his pass.
Rocket Scientist
Superstar
Amazing when TO left McNabb fell off even with young Desean Jackson and Maclin.Vick actually got better as a QB as he got older.